Doug,
It seems to be within normal conditions that you have a 20%/5 year
failure rate, but the sample is way too small to make any sort of
scientific determination. Certain types of drives are of course better
than others, and drives can degrade substantially without actually
failing. It's also hard to tell how long they might have lasted if it
averaged 20F lower than it is now, or what affect raising the
temperature on the weekends only might cause.
The bottom line is would seem to be what the potential cost to the
business is when a server completely goes down, either to be rebuilt,
restored, due to multiple drive failures, or failure of some other
component due to heat. You clearly aren't a banking institution,
though depending on circumstances, your servers might be just as vital
and therefore worth the extra ~$20/month that it costs to keep them
cooler...or maybe not. Ever wonder why good backup software costs more
than the OS?
Matt
Doug Traylor wrote:
I agree that the room should be much
cooler, I hate coming in on the weekends here, but the management has
an "if it ain't broke don't fix it" attitude and point out that we have
had no significant problems over 5 years so why change things now. We
have had a few drives (4 out of 20) fail over the years, some internal,
some in a Powervault, but nothing that seems out of the ordinary for 5
year old 10k rpm drives that are always on. Since they are all raided,
it has not caused us any trouble yet and we simply replace the drive
under our sevice contract. I always look at it as an opportunity to
get more drive space as they don't make drives that small anymore.
Upgrading our drives one at a time.
:o)
4 failures out of 20 drives over 5
years. Does that seem too high a failure rate or about average?
If it could be proven that the high
temps are causing drive failures the management might be a bit more
interested in upgrading the AC system in the computer room.
Doug
-----
Original Message -----
Sent:
Friday, August 12, 2005 11:30 AM
Subject:
Re: [Declude.Virus] OT - Server Room Temperature
Doug,
Hard drives are probably the most sensitive components that you have in
your servers, and I am not aware of any hard drives that should be run
above 50C/122F. My server runs about 35F hotter for the system temp
than the environment and about 40F hotter for the CPU's than the
environment. Note that these readings are under normal load, but when
the server redlines, the CPU's increase by about 15F and the system by
about 5F. Considering that the hard drives create heat themselves and
their much lower tolerance for heat in comparison to solid state
components, it would seem that going over 30C/85F for the ambient
temperature would be very dangerous as far as the hard drives go in an
active server. Hard drives will likely go over their operating
temperature long before the system or the processors unless you have a
broken fan or bad connection with a heat sync. My system is spec'd at
15C/27F over the hard drive's tolerance, and my CPU's at 27C/50F over.
IMO, 66F is the proper server room temperature, and it gives some
leeway for adding more equipment and other issues that can crop up such
as A/C failures. 72F would be the high end normal temp that I would
want to see. If my colo was over 75F, I would definitely complain.
The guy next to me with 25 TB's of 15,000 RPM SCSI drives would
probably complain louder :)
Matt
Doug Traylor wrote:
We just looked at the operating
spec of our servers from the Manufacturer's (Dell) website. The max is
listed as 95* F and we run around 80* F during the day on weekdays and
up to 92* F on the weekends when they turn off the AC in the plant. We
have our own AC which runs 24/7 in the computer room/closet. So far we
have not had any noticeable system problems in the five years we have
been operating this way.
When we had a large IBM
mainframe with all the dressing, we kept it in a large computer room
that was kept at a chilly 66* F. I was a computer operator then and
worked in there for 8-12 hours a day. I would wear two shirts and
longs sleeves to work, even when it was 110* F outside - Texas.
Doug
-----
Original Message -----
Sent:
Thursday, August 11, 2005 8:58 AM
Subject:
[Declude.Virus] OT - Server Room Temperature
Can someone point me to a
source of information regarding what temperature a server room should
be at ?
Thank you.
|