dev  

Messages by Date

• 2025/10/18 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/18 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Dheeraj Turaga
• 2025/10/18 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Scheduler does unnecessary processing when there are very large scheduled dags asquator
• 2025/10/18 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/18 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Vincent Beck
• 2025/10/18 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 01, 2025 Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Task priority weights are flawed Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/18 [RESULT][VOTE] Airflow Providers - release of October 04, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/18 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Dheeraj Turaga
• 2025/10/18 Re: Simplified Contributor's Quick Start is here! Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/18 Re: [Lazy Concensus] Wrap up the Pydocstyle project Daniel Standish via dev
• 2025/10/18 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Buğra Öztürk
• 2025/10/18 Re: Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Shahar Epstein
• 2025/10/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Avi via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Rahul Vats
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Avi via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 28, 2025 Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Scheduler does unnecessary processing when there are very large scheduled dags asquator
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Zhe-You(Jason) Liu
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/10/17 Re: Adding Greek translation Buğra Öztürk
• 2025/10/17 Re: SQLAlchemy 2 migration Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/17 Re: [Lazy Concensus] Wrap up the Pydocstyle project Kataria, Ramit
• 2025/10/17 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Hussein Awala
• 2025/10/17 Re: Adding Greek translation Shahar Epstein
• 2025/10/17 Re: Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Josef Šimánek
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Aritra Basu
• 2025/10/17 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 28, 2025 Hussein Awala
• 2025/10/17 Re: Simplified Contributor's Quick Start is here! Shahar Epstein
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Dev iL
• 2025/10/17 Re: [Lazy Concensus] Wrap up the Pydocstyle project Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 Re: AI-Native Airflow - LLM-Driven Intelligence for Production Data Workflows Kaxil Naik
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Ankit Chaurasia
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Shahar Epstein
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc1 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc1 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Daniel Standish via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Daniel Standish via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/10/17 Re: Simplified Contributor's Quick Start is here! Josef Šimánek
• 2025/10/17 Re: AI-Native Airflow - LLM-Driven Intelligence for Production Data Workflows Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on September 28, 2025 are released Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/10/17 [RESULT][VOTE] Airflow Providers - release of September 28, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/17 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 04, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Josef Šimánek
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow 3.0 Feathercast (was Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.3 Released) Rich Bowen
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Kiruban Kamaraj
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Vincent Beck
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Ferruzzi, Dennis
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Shahar Epstein
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Pratiksha Badheka
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Constance Martineau via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Daniel Standish via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Rahul Vats
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/10/17 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Constance Martineau via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Finalizing “DAG” terminology for docs and blog ("dag" vs "DAG" vs "Dag") Kaxil Naik
• 2025/10/17 Re: Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/17 Re: AI-Native Airflow - LLM-Driven Intelligence for Production Data Workflows Amogh Desai
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Briana Steel via dev
• 2025/10/17 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/15 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/10/15 Re: New PMC members: VIncent Beck, Wei Lee and committer: Guan Ming Kevin Yang
• 2025/10/15 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/15 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Constance Martineau via dev
• 2025/10/15 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Daniel Standish via dev
• 2025/10/15 Re: [VOTE] dag vs DAG vs Dag Buğra Öztürk
• 2025/10/15 Re: Inquiry Regarding Support, Billing, and Licensing for Apache Kafka & Airflow Docker Deployments Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/14 [Lazy Concensus] Wrap up the Pydocstyle project Ferruzzi, Dennis
• 2025/10/14 Re: Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Avi via dev
• 2025/10/14 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Bishundeo, Rajeshwar
• 2025/10/14 RE: Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Gyeongmo Yang
• 2025/10/13 🎟️ Access included: Join Airflow Summit Online Reconnect Teyza Ponce
• 2025/10/13 Re: [DISCUSS] Task priority weights are flawed Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/10/12 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Dheeraj Turaga
• 2025/10/10 Re: [DISCUSS] AIP-89: Privacy-First Telemetry for Apache Airflow Oliveira, Niko
• 2025/10/10 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Rahul Vats
• 2025/10/06 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow 3.0 Feathercast (was Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.3 Released) Rich Bowen
• 2025/10/06 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on October 04, 2025 are released Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/06 Re: [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Aritra Basu
• 2025/10/05 [DISCUSS]: Proposal to focus on polishing Airflow 3 Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/10/05 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 04, 2025 Hussein Awala
• 2025/10/04 [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 04, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/03 Adding Greek translation Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/10/02 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 01, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/02 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 01, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/01 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 01, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/10/01 [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 01, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/10/01 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on October 01, 2025 Dheeraj Turaga
• 2025/09/30 ⏳ Only 2 weeks left: Join Airflow Summit 2025 in Seattle 🎙️ Teyza Ponce
• 2025/09/30 AI-Native Airflow - LLM-Driven Intelligence for Production Data Workflows Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/09/28 Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/28 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 28, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/09/28 Re: [DISCUSS] Scheduler does unnecessary processing when there are very large scheduled dags Jens Scheffler
• 2025/09/28 [DISCUSS] Task priority weights are flawed asquator
• 2025/09/28 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 28, 2025 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/28 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 are released Elad Kalif
• 2025/09/28 [RESULT][VOTE] Airflow Providers - release of September 25, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/09/28 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Hussein Awala
• 2025/09/27 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/09/27 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/09/26 Re: [REMINDER] Complete i18n locales for Airflow 3.1 RC by Sep. 9, 2025 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/26 Re: [REMINDER] Complete i18n locales for Airflow 3.1 RC by Sep. 9, 2025 Shahar Epstein
• 2025/09/26 Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/26 [RESULT] [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Briana Steel via dev
• 2025/09/26 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Zhe-You(Jason) Liu
• 2025/09/26 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Vincent Beck
• 2025/09/26 Re: Simplified Contributor's Quick Start is here! Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/26 Re: [DISCUSS] Scheduler does unnecessary processing when there are very large scheduled dags Natanel
• 2025/09/26 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/25 [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: Airflow website's build environment has been modernized Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Ephraim Anierobi
• 2025/09/25 Backporting/Cherry-picking & Marking issues & PRs for Airflow >3.1.0 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: Airflow website's build environment has been modernized Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: Airflow website's build environment has been modernized Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/09/25 Airflow website's build environment has been modernized Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/09/25 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.1.0 & Task SDK 1.1.0 Released Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 [RESULT][ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/25 🎙️Airflow Summit 2025: 50 use cases on how to use Apache Airflow 👀 Teyza Ponce
• 2025/09/25 Cancelling dev call for today Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/09/25 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow 3.0 Feathercast (was Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.3 Released) Bishundeo, Rajeshwar
• 2025/09/25 RE: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow 3.0 Feathercast (was Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.3 Released) Scheffler Jens (XC-AS/EAE-ADA-T) via dev
• 2025/09/25 RE: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Blain David
• 2025/09/25 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow 3.0 Feathercast (was Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.3 Released) Bowen, Rich
• 2025/09/25 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/09/25 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow 3.0 Feathercast (was Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.3 Released) Bowen, Rich
• 2025/09/25 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Brent Bovenzi via dev
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Eugen Kosteev
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/09/25 [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on September 25, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/09/25 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/25 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Wei Lee
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Rahul Vats
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Phani Kumar via dev
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month constance.astronomer.io via dev
• 2025/09/24 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/09/24 Re: Simplified Contributor's Quick Start is here! Vincent Beck
• 2025/09/24 Re: [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Jens Scheffler
• 2025/09/24 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Jens Scheffler
• 2025/09/24 [VOTE] September 2025 PR of the Month Briana Steel via dev
• 2025/09/24 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Vincent Beck
• 2025/09/24 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Constance Martineau via dev
• 2025/09/24 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/09/24 Simplified Contributor's Quick Start is here! Amogh Desai
• 2025/09/24 RE: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Blain David
• 2025/09/23 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/09/23 Re: [ACCELERATED VOTE] Release Airflow 3.1.0. from 3.1.0rc2 & Task SDK 1.1.0 from 1.1.0rc2 Vikram Koka via dev
• 2025/09/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Scheduler does unnecessary processing when there are very large scheduled dags Matthew Phillips
• 2025/09/23 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Brent Bovenzi via dev
• 2025/09/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Scheduler does unnecessary processing when there are very large scheduled dags asquator
• 2025/09/23 Re: [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Vincent Beck
• 2025/09/23 [Discuss] Improving Airflow UI Testing Coverage Rahul Vats
• 2025/09/22 Re: [DISCUSS] Upcoming FAB 5 (we have a green PR!) needs more eyes Vincent Beck
• 2025/09/22 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on September 18, 2025 are released Elad Kalif
• 2025/09/21 Re: [DISCUSS] Retry on parsing file in task runner Daniel Standish via dev
• 2025/09/20 (airflow) branch dependabot/npm_and_yarn/airflow-core/src/airflow/api_fastapi/auth/managers/simple/ui/core-ui-package-updates-79efc081e4 updated (5b0e46d767f -> 47e3fe08dfa) github-bot
• 2025/09/20 Re: [Discussion] Make the scheduler's task selection algorithm pluggable asquator
• 2025/09/20 [PR] Add guards for registering middlewares from plugins [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] chore(ui): add bottom padding dag list [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] Fix the misalignment of gantt view progress bars (#55061) [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 (airflow) 03/03: Add release notes for 3.1.0b1 kaxilnaik
• 2025/09/20 Re: [I] Getting 'Not authenticated' error for airflowctl commands [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] [Filters] Add filtering support to Search – DAG Runs [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [I] all_done trigger rule goes upstream_failed when mapped inputs are all skipped [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 [PR] CI: Fix static checks in boring-cyborg.yml [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] Fix airflowctl test type mapping [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [I] Asset Aware Scheduling - Getting the logical date of the asset which triggered the dag. [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [D] S3TaskHandler doesn't seem to run the close method and doesn't push the logs to S3 [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 [PR] chore(ui): add bottom padding dag list [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] CI: Update blacken-docs rev version in pre-commit file [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 [I] Calendar failed view showing success runs [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] [Filters] Add filtering support to Search – DAG Runs [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] Move out some exceptions to TaskSDK [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 [I] Airflow emits INFO logs despite logging_level=ERROR [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 [PR] Disable backporting label auto-adding [airflow] via GitHub
• 2025/09/20 Re: [PR] Add CI job to test airflow standalone startup [airflow] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages