Thanks for raising this, Shrividya. I am totally in favor of simplifying
templates.

One thing I wanted to clarify on the current two-field setup: the dropdown
covers the common versions (2.x, 3.x latest, main), and the secondary text
field is there for users who pick "Other Airflow 3 version" so they are not
really redundant, they serve different purposes.

My hesitation with a fully free-text field is the version format. 3.1.8,
v3.1.8, airflow 3.1.8, 3.1 are all valid ways someone might type the same
version. The placeholder added in the PR helps, but it does not enforce a
format. One thing worth exploring: can the "If Other Airflow 3 version
selected, which one?" field be shown conditionally only when "Other Airflow
3 version" is selected in the dropdown? That would reduce the visual noise
without losing the structure we have today.

Also +1 to Shahar's idea of unifying the core and providers bug report
templates. That feels like the bigger simplification win in reducing the
current template count.

Thanks,
Rahul

Reply via email to