-1 (non binding) gradle discourages contributions which is a big pitfall for an asf project and maven/gradle comparison is unfair due to the threading setup of maven (hardcoded thread count and no parallelize builder tusage).
Le 28 nov. 2017 19:38, "Jason Kuster" <jasonkus...@google.com> a écrit : > +1 > > From the perspective of Beam's infrastructure, I've found that Gradle > provides us a good amount more flexibility to do the kinds of builds we > want. Additionally, the shorter run times (while not the only factor here) > will allow us to stretch our finite executor resources further, leading to > fewer instances where people are waiting for other builds to finish for > their presubmits to start. > > On Tue, Nov 28, 2017 at 10:22 AM, Chamikara Jayalath <chamik...@google.com > > wrote: > >> +1 >> >> And thanks Luke for clearly mentioning the migration process. Let's make >> sure that all major use cases of Maven are properly addressed before >> removing Maven support. >> >> Thanks, >> Cham >> >> >> On Tue, Nov 28, 2017 at 10:09 AM Wesley Tanaka <wtanaka+b...@wtanaka.com> >> wrote: >> >>> +1 >>> >>> >>> On 11/28/2017 07:55 AM, Lukasz Cwik wrote: >>> >>> This is a procedural vote for migrating to use Gradle for all our >>> development related processes (building, testing, and releasing). A >>> majority vote will signal that: >>> * Gradle build files will be supported and maintained alongside any >>> remaining Maven files. >>> * Once Gradle is able to replace Maven in a specific process (or portion >>> thereof), Maven will no longer be maintained for said process (or portion >>> thereof) and will be removed. >>> >>> +1 I support the process change >>> 0 I am indifferent to the process change >>> -1 I would like to remain with our current processes >>> >>> ------------------------------------------------------------ >>> ---------------------------------------- >>> >>> Below is a summary of information contained in the disucssion thread >>> comparing Gradle and Maven: https://lists.apache.org/threa >>> d.html/225dddcfc78f39bbb296a0d2bbef1caf37e17677c7e5573f0b6fe >>> 253@%3Cdev.beam.apache.org%3E >>> >>> Gradle (mins) >>> min: 25.04 >>> max: 160.14 >>> median: 45.78 >>> average: 52.19 >>> stdev: 30.80 >>> >>> Maven (mins) >>> min: 56.86 >>> max: 216.55 (actually > 240 mins because this data does not include >>> timeouts) >>> median: 87.93 >>> average: 109.10 >>> stdev: 48.01 >>> >>> Maven >>> Java Support: Mature >>> Python Support: None (via mvn exec plugin) >>> Go Support: Rudimentary (via mvn plugin) >>> Protobuf Support: Rudimentary (via mvn plugin) >>> Docker Support: Rudimentary (via mvn plugin) >>> ASF Release Automation: Mature >>> Jenkins Support: Mature >>> Configuration Language: XML >>> Multiple Java Versions: Yes >>> Static Analysis Tools: Some >>> ASF Release Audit Tool (RAT): Rudimentary (plugin complete and >>> longstanding but poor) >>> IntelliJ Integration: Mature >>> Eclipse Integration: Mature >>> Extensibility: Mature (updated per JB from discuss thread) >>> Number of GitHub Projects Using It: 146k >>> Continuous build daemon: None >>> Incremental build support: None (note that this is not the same as >>> incremental compile support offered by the compiler plugin) >>> Intra-module dependencies: Rudimentary (requires the use of many >>> profiles to get per runner dependencies) >>> >>> Gradle >>> Java Support: Mature >>> Python Support: Rudimentary (pygradle, lacks pypi support) >>> Go Support: Rudimentary (gogradle plugin) >>> Protobuf Support: Rudimentary (via protobuf plugin) >>> Docker Support: Rudimentary (via docker plugin) >>> ASF Release Automation: ? >>> Jenkins Support: Mature >>> Configuration Language: Groovy >>> Multiple Java Versions: Yes >>> Static Analysis Tools: Some >>> ASF Release Audit Tool (RAT): Rudimentary (plugin just calls Apache >>> Maven ANT plugin) >>> IntelliJ Integration: Mature >>> Eclipse Integration: Mature >>> Extensibility: Mature >>> Number of GitHub Projects Using It: 122k >>> Continuous build daemon: Mature >>> Incremental build support: Mature >>> Intra-module dependencies: Mature (via configurations) >>> >>> >>> -- >>> Wesley Tanakahttps://wtanaka.com/ >>> >>> > > > -- > ------- > Jason Kuster > Apache Beam / Google Cloud Dataflow >
