guyuqi commented on PR #1053: URL: https://github.com/apache/bigtop/pull/1053#issuecomment-1326186976
> > To fix the issues of Ambari metrics, Phoenix should be algined to Hadoop and Hbase version which are conformance to Bigtop stack version. (For example, we should update HBase 2.4.1+ to 2.4.13 for phoenix-hbase-compat) > > I'm -1 on migrating old Ambari (2.7.5) to Hadoop 3.3 as sub-task of Bigtop 3.2. It takes too much time. Since Ambari is live project now, migrating Ambari to Hadoop 3.3 should be done in Ambari project first. We may be able to cherry pick the work to old Ambari if you want. > > We should release Bigtop 3.2 as soon as possible since bumping Hadoop to 3.3 is quite a big change. Migrating Ambari should be done in parallel effort. > > @guyuqi @iwasakims The work of migrating Ambari-2.7.5 to Hadoop 3.3 have almost done in BIGTOP-3689. Zhiguo, Yuhou and I who were working on BIGTOP-3689 reached the agreement that the MPack provided by Bigtop-3.2 will take the the latest Bigtop-3.2 packages rather than 3.1's packages. Though the tasks in BIGTOP-3689 were named `xxx support for Bigtop 3.1 Mpack` (I'm sorry it looks a little bit confused), the related done work were acctually based on our latest Bigtop for Bigtop-3.2. It is why Zhiguo Wu asked Kengo for help (BIGTOP-3745) to provide a snapshot repository for latest rpm packages when we were working on BIGTOP-3689. In a word, Bigtop have supported Ambari-2.7.5 + new Bigtop 3.2 stack(Hadoop 3.3) + Mpack. What to do next is just to find a place (Bigtop public repo) to store the related Bigtop Binary-TARs as Hortonworks did. For this PR: As you mentioned: "We are usually using [do-component-build](https://github.com/apache/bigtop/blob/master/bigtop-packages/src/common/phoenix/do-component-build) to adjust versions if it can be overridden by just properties." I'd like to rebuild ambari-mertrics by adjusting versions [on building ambari-metrics](https://github.com/apache/bigtop/blob/c61cb82b86b76478f8f0d8f1b391feffc5aa2a47/bigtop-packages/src/common/ambari/do-component-build#L37), and revert this PR . If the test is ok, I will close this PR (no needed) and update https://github.com/apache/bigtop/pull/1054. Thanks for your comments. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
