On 8/11/06, Jorg Heymans <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Daniel Fagerstrom wrote: >>> -0, because this means eliminating cocoon 2.2 on "older" application >>> servers eg weblogic 8.1. > IIUC weblogic 8.1 uses servlet 2.3 so I guess you need to veto the use > of servlet 2.4 to make this a valid point. > I felt that my current involvement in cocoon is not big enough to warrant a veto, hence the -0 here. WLS 8.1 was just an example from my past experience, but technically you're right ofcourse.
Based on the "Voting Policies" thread I think it's legitimate for me to ask if you can give us a _compelling_ reason why you need to run Cocoon 2.2 on a platform that does not have Java 5 support and why running Cocoon 2.1 instead isn't sufficient? If you have a real use case that requires Cocoon 2.2 on some platform that does not support Java 5 then I think a veto would be appropriate. Otherwise, I think a -0 would be a good indication of concern. -- Peter Hunsberger
