There's nothing wrong with the practice except that a vote thread with comments means that we probably shouldn't proceed and should discuss it more. Too much discussion on vote thread means we don't have any sort of consensus and should work that out first.
On Thu, Apr 9, 2015, 12:52 PM Andrew Grieve <agri...@chromium.org> wrote: > Have become very common for us. Probably because the release VOTE is the > thing that actually gets people motivated to take a good look. > > Thought it'd be good for us to discuss this practice. > > My thoughts: > - I think it still makes sense to DISCUSS before starting a release > - I think it's perfectly reasonable to go through several RCs as things > come up during testing (RCs are easy) > - I think it helps to have the blog post ready before a vote (I made this > change to the platforms release process this time around) > - I don't have any problem with VOTE threads that are full of discussion. > What's the concern? >
