Topic: Should this be version 4.0.0, not 3.5.0? The OGSI-package-name-changes have broken many schemas because the test rigs used Daffodil internals, and some deprecated things were finally removed in the current 3.5.0 snapshot.
But as a result, these schemas, many of which are non-public, but nevertheless can be counted, a long list, which used to work, don't work any more. It's possible there are false-negatives here. Nevertheless it is a long list. [fail] (04/62) dfdl-bmp [fail] (11/62) dfdl-examples-hexwords [fail] (12/62) dfdl-examples-self-descriptive-data [fail] (13/62) dfdl-examples-xslt-csv [fail] (22/62) dfdl-imf-icalendar-cse [fail] (23/62) dfdl-ipf-demo [fail] (29/62) dfdl-jpeg2000 [fail] (30/62) dfdl-jreap [fail] (34/62) dfdl-mil-std-2045 [fail] (38/62) dfdl-nitf [fail] (42/62) dfdl-plc4x-s7 [fail] (43/62) dfdl-png [fail] (46/62) dfdl-raster [fail] (49/62) dfdl-stanag-5516 [fail] (50/62) dfdl-stanag-5516-with-nact [fail] (53/62) dfdl-usmtf [fail] (54/62) dfdl-usmtf-generic [fail] (57/62) dfdl-vmf [fail] (59/62) dfdl-vmf-spock [fail] (61/62) ibm-dfdl-crosstester This suggests to me that user-created schemas have some fairly high likelihood of being clobbered. We changed the packages of many things. We can claim these were internal things, but there are many schemas that depend on Daffodil internal things now. This needs to get fixed so we can torque the internals more without breaking things, but right now... things are broken. Every schema using layers, for example as we never hardened the API for layers, so as it has evolved, schemas have broken. On Mon, Jun 5, 2023 at 6:07 PM Mike Beckerle <mbecke...@apache.org> wrote: > > All critical and blocker type bugs have been fixed including a couple > quite challenging ones in the last few weeks. > > I think it is time to create an RC for 3.5.0. > > Please discuss through 6pm EDT.US on Thursday June 8. (72 hours) and if > favorable we'll figure out who gets to create the RC. > > -mikeb > > Mike Beckerle > Apache Daffodil PMC | daffodil.apache.org > OGF DFDL Workgroup Co-Chair | www.ogf.org/ogf/doku.php/standards/dfdl/dfdl > Owl Cyber Defense | www.owlcyberdefense.com > > >
