On Dec 12, 2012, at 1:08 AM, Shawn Heisey <[email protected]> wrote:
> On 12/11/2012 8:19 PM, Mark Miller wrote: >> I think there are two different issues at least going on - mostly around >> replication. Just happens the solrcloud tests do a lot of that, so they tend >> to pick up on issues there. >> >> I look and see if they are slower than normal - my test runs are looking a >> little longer lately, but not by too much. >> >> The BasicDistributedZk* test are actually many tests rolled up into one - >> mostly to save time on jetty construction/destruction steps. That is part of >> why they are longer. There are a few things that add up - one is that we >> start jetties sequentially due to system properyy issues - we also currently >> stop them sequentially, just because no one has gotten to doing that in >> parallel. There are a variety of other things as well. >> >> These tests end up catching many none solrcloud bugs though - most of the >> solrcloud stuff is built on existing features and stresses them more than >> usual. > > If the amount of time that these tests is taking is considered normal > (consistently just over 4 minutes for the one test/seed I singled out to > fail), then I'll just have to live with it. Since these tests do catch bugs, > they are good things to have. > > I'm just feeling annoyance that the build time is dominated by tests for > features I don't use, especially because when I have a test failure, it's > almost always those tests. I'll get over it once the problems are found and > they stop failing so often. > > I haven't gotten a single successful test run since this morning, even when I > just run "ant clean test" from branch_4x/solr. I think it's time to go to > bed now. > > Thanks, > Shawn Well, I guess normal depends on who you are - for my machine it's closer to 2 minutes. If it's 4 minutes for a lot of people, it may make sense to break it into 2 sets. Right now these tests are catching a problem around replication and shutdown like I mentioned. The replication test hits the same thing sometimes, but much less often. If you don't use replication, you are right - this probably has no effect on you. But they are not SolrCloud specific fails. - Mark --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
