> On Jan 25, 2017, at 12:46 PM, Casey Stella <ceste...@gmail.com> wrote: > > On the whole, I think we're ready to graduate based on the maturity > checklist posted. I think the issues with the 0.3.0 build were resolved as > of METRON-600 (the new website with proper download links and appropriate > indication that we are an incubated project).
As a mentor, I feel metron is ready to graduate. > > The only thing that gives has given me pause is that we did find (and > correct as of METRON-283) a compile-time dependency on MySQL, a > non-compliant license derivative-work-wise. My remaining question would be > directed at the Mentors, are license review of graduating projects done on > the current codebase or the most recent release? If it's the most recent > release, then we should do a point-release after METRON-283 is in prior to > submitting for graduation. License reviews are done on a per release basis. What’s in your repo only matters when it comes time to make a release. In other words, if you have some category-x code/dependency in your repo, that’s fine, but needs to be corrected in order to release. If your last release was affected by METRON-283 (had a compile time dependency of a cat-x licensed artifact) I would recommend doing a point release. > > Beyond that, I am most interested in the opinions of the Mentors. Do you > see any barriers that we should address? If we can anticipate issues, we > should correct them before going through the effort of trying to graduate. I think you’re ready. > > Casey -Taylor > > On Mon, Jan 23, 2017 at 7:09 PM, James Sirota <jsir...@apache.org> wrote: > >> I think the Apache Incubation was very valuable learning experience for >> us, but it seems like we are ready to become a top-level project. We have >> been in incubation since 2015-12-06 and under the guidance of our Mentors >> we had a clean build (0.3.0), we learned how to function well as a >> community (as defined by Apache), and if you look at our maturity level >> checklist we meet the criteria of the a mature Apache project. ( >> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=66852119) >> >> >> Do you think we are ready to graduate? Should we start putting a case >> together for graduation? >> >> ------------------- >> Thank you, >> >> James Sirota >> PPMC- Apache Metron (Incubating) >> jsirota AT apache DOT org >>
