About the build: Use Option 1, non-mavenize. That shall be fairly easy.
On 12/28/20 7:39 AM, Eric Bresie wrote:
I may have found the main source of my problems...
I started with netbeans-contrib version from Tim [1] which is maven based.
Is there any use case where some of the code is maven based and built with
the top level ant build infrastructure?
More specific details...
I merged and move stuff out of contrib into a top level python cluster
folder at the same level as others (i.e. cpp-lite, php, groovy, etc.) with
all the related sub-projects (jython and python) underneath. I updated
the cluster.properties files and was continuing to get the build issues.
I finally realized the netbeans-contribute version I pulled may have been a
“proof of concept” to convert over to maven based build versions of the
contrib projects. And as such there are no ant equivalent build files
present there. So assume because of this the ant build doesn’t know how to
handle these.
I tried building one of the modules with maven and it built fine...
Since the main build is presently utilizing ant, is there a way to have the
ant build pick up a maven sub projects build?
Would it be better to
(1) attempt to retrieve the “non-mavenized” version and merge that one
instead? My hesitation is I thought Tim had made some updates along the
way beyond just mavenizing but I may be wrong there.
(2) implement some build logic to allow mixture of ant/maven builds
(3) wait for the “maven” based Netbeans builds in development
(4) recreate python as a new LSP client language (and/or kind of a
python-lite similar to cpp-lite)?
Specific question on the architecture of the python projects. Are the
jython and python sub-project independent of each other? Or are the coupled
in some way? Just trying to see if this would really be two different
flavors of support or if they should be packaged together and/or need to be
together.
Regarding build artifact/dependencies..
While reviewing the maven version Pom file for o.jython and it was not
finding the dependencies quite as expected as it was looking under Central
Repository: org/netbeans (apache.org)
<https://repo.maven.apache.org/maven2/org/netbeans/> for which there
appears to be no such jython or python dependencies there. I believe
previous ones may have been picked up but still I was wondering...Given the
move to Apache and not fully being donated/integrated, am I correct in
saying these dependencies are no longer published there? And if not, what
would need to be done to get the proper dependencies published? Is this a
matter of once integrated and start getting including in the master source
repository allowing the jars to be built they would then start being
publishers there? Have these dependencies been moved elsewhere?
I see some jython dependencies available under Central Repository:
org/python (apache.org) <https://repo.maven.apache.org/maven2/org/python/> so
assuming maybe it may require usage of some of these in some way but that’s
just a guess.
Were these published by the jython/python developers and should not be part
of NB build context?
[1] timboudreau/netbeans-contrib: Fork of netbeans contrib repo (github.com)
<https://github.com/timboudreau/netbeans-contrib>
Eric
On Mon, Dec 21, 2020 at 12:48 AM Jaroslav Tulach <[email protected]>
wrote:
Hello Eric,
thanks for taking care of porting Python support to Apache NetBeans. Your
work shall not be lost. The sources are supposed to be part of next
donation to Apache, it is just taking ages to get the approvals. We are
missing the driving force of Geertjan...
nb.cluster.python.dir=python
nb.cluster.python.depends=\
nb.cluster.ide
nb.cluster.python=\
o.jython,\
o.jython.distro,\
python.console,\
python.core,\
python.debugger,\
python.editor,\
python.help,\
python.hints,\
python.kit,\
python.options,\
python.platform,\
python.project,\
python.project2,\
python.samples,\
python.source,\
python.testrunner
Right, creating own cluster (like php) is good idea.
C:\git\netbeans.ebresie\netbeans\python\o.jython
This is the right location for the files. Try to go into that directory and
use `ant build` in there. Once the projects compile one by one, we can try
to analyze the failure when compiling the whole cluster. Just 2Kč advice...
-jt
so 19. 12. 2020 v 16:23 odesílatel Eric Bresie <[email protected]> napsal:
Maybe someone familiar with the python project can chime in...
After a few further tweaks in the cluster.properties file I still
continue
to get
$ ant -Dcluster.config=python | tee >> build.output.txt
[copy] Warning: Could not find file
<>\netbeans\nbbuild\gitinfo.properties to copy.
[copy] Warning: Could not find
file <>\\netbeans\nbbuild\netbeansrelease.properties to copy.
BUILD FAILED
<>\\netbeans\nbbuild\build.xml:277: Cannot resolve python/o.jython.
Neither
one exist:
<>\\netbeans\python\o.jython
<>\\netbeans\python\python\o.jython
I'm starting to think the o.jython mentioned in some way requires a
binary
download of some jython jars which is missing and not getting pulled
down.
In the build.xml mention of downloadbinaries associated with the
nbuild\external\binaries-list. Assuming cluster specific is defined in a
cluster specific version of the "external\binaries-list". So my thinking
is somehow whatever causes the higher level to link up with the cluster
lower levels is not getting downloads correctly. Is there maybe some
configuration I might be missing here?
Eric Bresie
[email protected]
On Fri, Dec 11, 2020 at 12:41 PM Eric Bresie <[email protected]> wrote:
As a learning project, I am trying to get python working in netbeans.
One of my first steps was to make a python branch on github based on my
fork from the main netbeans project, pulled down the contrib code from
the
hg repository including the python related projects and start plugging
away
at it.
The files for the project used to be located under contrib/python (and
jython)" but I thought if acceptable, might be better to move it into a
"top level" project (similar to php). As part of this, I moved the
folders
and started updating the clusters.properties file to add applicable
python
items and to move out of the other area so the current iteration of
this
looks like:
nb.cluster.python.dir=python
nb.cluster.python.depends=\
nb.cluster.ide
nb.cluster.python=\
o.jython,\
o.jython.distro,\
python.console,\
python.core,\
python.debugger,\
python.editor,\
python.help,\
python.hints,\
python.kit,\
python.options,\
python.platform,\
python.project,\
python.project2,\
python.samples,\
python.source,\
python.testrunner
However, when attempting to build with
ant clean -Dcluster.config=python build
I get an error like:
BUILD FAILED
C:\git\netbeans.ebresie\netbeans\nbbuild\build.xml:1313: The following
error occurred while executing this line:
C:\git\netbeans.ebresie\netbeans\nbbuild\build.xml:277: Cannot resolve
o.jython. Neither one exist:
C:\git\netbeans.ebresie\netbeans\o.jython
C:\git\netbeans.ebresie\netbeans\python\o.jython
I tried in another form with the non-jython items and then it moved on
to
the next module so I think for some reason it is not finding the
modules
under ".dir" attribute defined above for some reason. I moved the
python
and jython related projects under a "python" top level folder which
assumed
it should find but for some reason
Anyone have any idea how to resolve this problem?
Eric Bresie
[email protected]
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
For further information about the NetBeans mailing lists, visit:
https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/NETBEANS/Mailing+lists
