Hi Pedro, Am 02.06.24 um 23:58 schrieb Pedro Lino:
Hi Aivaras, Matthias, allOn 06/02/2024 12:36 PM WEST Aivaras Stepukonis <astepuko...@gmail.com> wrote:The way I see it, we do need a designer for the new OO icon style to be complete and to look consistent and up-to-date. Thus, my proposal is to reach out and see whether we can attract one. I’ll make an effort to do so, but before I do, I need to collect additional information, so I can present our needs to the Iconify.design crowd in a clear and concise fashion. First off, what visual goals are we trying to achieve through the new icon style?I think it would be perfect to have a designer. If you can attract one that would be fantastic. For the moment Remixicon is a quite complete image set and apparently the authors are available to add new ones.As a result, our visual goal for the new icon style could be to produce a style that hearkens back to Galaxy but is further refined to look current and in line with the latest generation of OS (the most widespread being Windows 11) and productivity suites (the most widespread being Microsoft Office). The style should still be originally conceived and executed, with the roots in Galaxy (innovation of tradition, as it were). Does this sound like a reasonable path to tread in terms of our visual expectations?That would be my preference too. I think that monochromatic icons are dull and require more focus than colored ones which are more easily identifiable. But again, a custom designed icon set requires a designer. Using existing icons only requires technical skills.(I think it’s worth pursuing this task only if it is done well and feels like a stylistic upgrade; otherwise, the current set of icons isn’t broken, and needs no fix.)Current icon sets are not broken but they are incomplete. But this new icon set would bring not only a UI modernization (for those who want it) but most importantly to add a proper Dark Icon set instead of the High Contrast which is currently the Dark style by default.
That problem cannot be solved by a new icon set. This must be done in code! We need a logic to differentiate between High Contrast and Dark Mode.
But of course, when we have achieved this, we would need icon sets for Light UI, Dark UI and High Contrast.
If we decide to work on a new icon set it should be suitable for all these use cases. And we could make it the default theme in a later (major) release.
2024-05-31 22:31, Matthias Seidel wrote:Until we have consensus on this topic the PR will remain a draft open for everyone.First of all thank you for your effort to investigate how to add a new icon set! I would call this theme simply Remixicon (not remixdark) and the inverted, (i.e. light image icons) can be added in the same folder without affecting High Contrast. As I explained in a previous message the High Contrast icons are the fallback if the icon set does not contain the lch or sch icons. You (Matthias) can test this by simply copying the lch and sch icons I sent you in a zip to /source/openoffice/main/ooo_custom_images/remixdark/res/commandimagelist/ Please see a screenshot of my latest Linux build based on the Pilot-Pirx-iconset branch https://i.imgur.com/Gx0rlyo.png I believe these are excellent news because it solves the Linux Dark mode problem without affecting people who use the High Contrast icon style.
See my explanation above. Your image still shows High Contrast UI. This is NOT Dark mode. It is High Contrast with other icons.
The green elements (e.g. in Sidebar) are defined in our code, and there are many more of them. We cannot simply (mis)use HC icons for Dark Mode.
This would just be a "quick and dirty" solution, sorry. Regards, Matthias
With this said, if a designer can be attracted it would be ideal, regardless if he/she creates a new theme from scratch or creates a set based on Remixicon (or other existing icon set). All the best, Pedro --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@openoffice.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@openoffice.apache.org
smime.p7s
Description: Kryptografische S/MIME-Signatur
