So, firstly I want to echo what Gordon has said. Speaking for myself I am very grateful for the work you have been doing on the QMF adapter for the Java broker. I can only apologise for some of the issues that you hve found in terms of incompatibilities and I thank you for your patience in dealing with them.
Going forward I certainly want Qpid (both the Java and C++ brokers, as well as components coming out of the Proton workstream) to be using the standardised AMQP 1.0 management... but while the standard is currently focused on the mechanisms we have an opportunity as the Qpid community to look at how type definitions and behaviours can be standardised. I think any such work can only benefit from starting from the qork done in writing the QMF adapter. I would hope that we would be looking to adapt your GUI tool to use AMQP management as it (AMQP management) matures (perhaps directly using AMQP over websockets and a Proton JavaScript engine?). In the meantime have you got a list of all the areas where the Java Broker and C++ broker are incompatible? I'm sure Gordon and I wouldbe very interested in that and would do our utmost to try to narrow that gap. Thanks again, Rob On 25 March 2013 20:43, Gordon Sim <[email protected]> wrote: > On 03/25/2013 07:25 PM, Fraser Adams wrote: >> >> I'd have no problem migrating things to something new (sigh!!) but I >> really think that the QMF Management GUI I put together is pretty good >> and I had actually just got things working so that I could talk to both >> the C++ and Java brokers using both qpid-config and the QMF GUI, that >> consistency seemed pretty worthwhile IMHO. > > > I agree. The GUI tool was very nice and easy to use and fills a gap that no > one else had plugged (i.e. a graphical tool for managing the c++ broker). > > I have yet to try out the adapter to allow the same to be used against the > java broker, but I must say I'm impressed with your achievement there. > > I applaud your efforts in this area! Please do not be discouraged! The work > you have done is very valuable now as is the insights you will now be able > to bring to bear on future direction in this important area. > > --Gordon. > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
