I'm trying to use the new dialog stuff in a production app.
Previously I had only been using dialogs in popup windows (with no
browser back buttons to worry about.)  Now I think I'm running into
the same problems as Rahul and others have reported.  I will describe
my usecase where I think the results are unexpected.

I'm working on a website for a marina.  Most of the site navigation
links bring up other pages but when they click on "boats", a shale
dialog is started that helps them to browse the list of available
boats.  The dialog is completely transparent to the user.  The same
site menu navigation options appear on the page and the user has no
idea they are in a dialog.

If in the middle of browsing through the listing the user wants to
start over they will likely click the "boats" link again.  This time
it appears to do nothing.  In reality its starting the dialog which is
picking up where it "left off."  The end result is the user is
"stuck."

Is this really desirable behavior?  Maybe we should at least have the
option to restart the dialog?  Also, if the user bookmarks any of the
pages in the dialog, they are pretty much screwed.  I realize there is
a larger bookmarking in JSF issue here but I'm looking for some ideas.

TIA,

Sean

Reply via email to