+1 to moving auth out of commons and moving the other auth bundles to bundles/auth.
Not loving the package change, but I agree it is a good idea and better to be done now than later. On Aug 13, 2010, at 10:01 AM, Felix Meschberger <fmesc...@gmail.com> wrote: > Hi all, > > We are in the end game of releasing the Sling Authenticator Bundle (aka > Commons Auth). > > Carsten an I have been discussing about this bundle and are considering > moving this bundle out of the commons area. > > The reason for this is, that the commons area has once been designated > to be a location with usefull helper stuff but with not API dependency > to Sling. Since we moved part of Commons Auth to the API, this does not > hold any longer for the Commons Auth bundle. > > As a consequence, we would have to rename the packages from > o.a.s.commons.auth to o.a.s.auth (probably). This is mainly an issue > because the exported packages ...auth and ...auth.spi are being used > elsewhere (e.g. for implementing authentication handlers). > > I suggest we create a new location bundles/auth where we move the > Authenticator bundle along with the OpenID and Form authentication > handlers (currently below bundles/extensions). > > As a consequence the API packages o.a.s.commons.auth and > o.a.s.commons.auth.spi would be renamed to o.a.s.auth and > o.a.s.auth.spi, resp. > > Moving the bundle is tracked in SLING-1650. > > WDYT ? > > Regards > Felix > > [1] https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SLING-1650
