I would go ahead and hold a formal PPMC vote on Graduation now. Please go ahead and do it.
On Thu, Jun 15, 2017 at 7:05 AM, sblackmon <sblack...@apache.org> wrote: > To summarize, support for graduation exists among mentors, PPMC, and > incubator leadership. > > No specific objections have been raised, but far fewer have expressed > support in 7 days than currently hold PPMC votes. > > The next steps include drafting a charter and holding a formal PPMC [VOTE] > on Graduation. (see [1] and [2] below) > > Feel free to reply to this thread with additional thoughts until a VOTE > thread is opened. If you have concerns that you expect may cause you to > vote -1 or abstain, please voice them now. > > [1] https://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_ > Policy.html#Graduating+from+the+Incubator > [2] http://incubator.apache.org/guides/graduation.html#requirements > On June 12, 2017 at 10:03:59 AM, sblackmon (sblack...@apache.org) wrote: > > > John, responses to your comments in-line below. > > Steve > > On June 11, 2017 at 9:08:42 PM, John D. Ament (johndam...@apache.org) > wrote: > Hey guys > > Steve asked me to look over the dependencies in Streams to see if there's > any issues. > > I don't see any issues - the dependencies you have from a binary > standpoint are all Cat-A/Cat-B so its no issue. > > > Thanks for taking a look at the dependency tree. Good to hear you didn’t > find any red flags. > > I do have to question the scope of some of them though. If I were a user > of Streams, it may be that Streams brings in too many dependencies. Just > something to think about - can Streams be simplified? > > > Overall we are definitely in a consolidation phase. In the last two > releases, the number of modules that depend on guava have dropped > significantly, and we’ve gotten rid of third-party binary libraries > twitter4j and jInstagram (and their transitive dependencies) in master > branch. We are well on the way to dropping all third-party libraries for > which direct HTTP is a viable substitute. This trend will continue and > ultimately I expect we will be able to remove guava, typesafe, jackson, > jodatime, and jsonschema2pojo from core modules (all not under > streams-contrib). > > We’re also dropping modules from the project faster than new ones are > being added lately. Third-party libraries that use binary protocols to > connect with various databases are pretty well isolated from core > functionality already. If we manage to replace Streams interfaces and > execution with Beam interfaces and execution, as has been discussed > multiple times on the list with no dissenting voices, that would allow us > to delete or migrate a lot of non-differentiated capabilities (runtimes and > persisters) while overall increasing developer productivity around our > primary use cases (providers and processors). > > https://paste.apache.org/p/Xvtl - this is the raw output from maven. > > For instance. It looks like you have a scala plugin, but all modules are > dependent on scala. Is there maybe a bad dependency somewhere in the mix? > > The scala dependency is there to support serialization of scala > primitives, lists, maps, and other objects. It’s almost certainly the case > there is way we could make it optional. I opened STREAMS-514 to address > this. > > John > > On 2017-06-07 12:51 (-0400), sblackmon <sblack...@apache.org> wrote: > > Hello, > > > > I wanted to let everyone know that at ApacheCon Miami I received > encouragement from quite a few IPMC members to graduate the project to TLP. > > > > The June board report stated that we’ve completed the AMMA, and have > compiled a checklist of items that we might want or need to do before we > graduation.  The list is fairly short and contains few if any difficult or > essential tasks. > > > > It also stated that we are likely to ask to graduate before our next > IPMC report. > > > > So I’m opening a thread here to see if the community thinks we are > ready - and if we aren’t for any reason, what do you think we should do > before we ask the incubator to vote us to TLP? > > > > Thanks, > > Steve > > > > > > Here’s the Streams section of the board report for reference - copied > from https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/June2017 just now. > > > > -------------------- > > Streams > > > > Apache Streams (incubating) unifies a diverse world of digital profiles > and > > online activities into common formats and vocabularies, and makes these > > datasets accessible across a variety of databases, devices, and > platforms for > > streaming, browsing, search, sharing, and analytics use-cases. > > > > Streams has been incubating since 2012-11-20. > > > > Three most important issues to address in the move towards graduation: > > > > 1. Community growth and PMC maturity. > > 2. Demonstrate a consistent release schedule. > > 3. Participation of project community within related standards-bodies > and Apache projects. > > > > Any issues that the Incubator PMC (IPMC) or ASF Board wish/need to be > aware > > of? > > > > The community has completed an internal assessment using the Apache > Maturity Model to identify gaps that should be addressed before graduation. > > > > The community is working against a task list of graduation TODOs: > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/STREAMS/Graduation+TODOs > > > > It is likely that Streams will pursue graduation to TLP during the > coming quarter. > > > > How has the community developed since the last report? > > > > Dev List > > 57 emails sent by 12 people, divided into 20 topics > > > > Web Page > > 820 Sessions (up ~75%), 508 Users (up ~50%), 1507 Pageviews (up ~30%). > > > > Public Slack: apachestreams.slack.com > > 1202 Messages, 11 Files > > > > Committers Slack: the-asf.slack.com #dev-streams > > 157 Messages, 3 Files > > > > How has the project developed since the last report? > > > > Source Control > > https://github.com/apache/incubator-streams > > Excluding merges, 4 authors have pushed 29 commits to master. On master, > 165 files have changed and there have been 5,891 additions and 1,647 > deletions. > > > > https://github.com/apache/incubator-streams-examples > > Excluding merges, 3 authors have pushed 4 commits to master. On master, > 10 files have changed and there have been 18 additions and 72 deletions. > > > > JIRA > > > > 24 issues closed with 0.5-incubating release > > 7 issues closed after 0.5-incubating release > > 18 new issues opened this period > > > > Date of last release: > > > > 2017-03-20 : 0.5-incubating release > > > > When were the last committers or PMC members elected? > > > > 2017-04-14: Trevor Grant elected as committer / PPMC member > > > > Signed-off-by: > > > > [X](streams) Matt Franklin > > Comments: The community is small, but diverse and dedicated. I look > forward to seeing them move past the incubator and hopefully continuing to > add new contributors. > > [X](streams) Ate Douma > > Comments: > > [X](streams) Suneel Marthi > > Comments: > > > > >
