Hi Filip,

> I would like to finish the work with your
> comments. I have a small plan :-). Everybody should write his comments
> to this thread and I will try to make the changes which you will
> want.  Then, I can send you some "closer to final" state of the
> mockups and try to redesign it with your comments.

I really appreciate your work, but... (I know shitty start ;), I really do
appreciate the fact that you throw designs at us as well, which definitely
look good, and sometimes things stay abstract too long )

... but I am not sure whether we should just move forward, pick a design
and implement it now already. That is what we've done last time, and what
we have now is the result of that. For example, all your designs feature a
news section. We have never written down a requirement (this sounds very
formal, but it isn't at all that formal, it is just about ordering all of
our thoughts and results of investigations) for such a section. We should
first agree on what we want, instead of having the design dictate us what
is possible. I hope I do not hold your enthusiasm, but it is quite a
project to design for, there are many things we need to take into account,
and thus need some more thorough thinking than just about the nicest
configuration of elements we may even not be happy with in the first
place.

Btw. what do you think about a menubar? Do you think your design should do
without (since you have never added one), or have you always considered
your design to feature the menubar? I believe that is a very useful
element, especially to cater for those who are more experienced, what do
you think?

g.,


Maarten

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to