Hello all,
I've been trying to figure the best way to handle this situation for the better
part of two days... and so I figured I'd bring it on list and hopefully I can
clarify this all. I have several projects that relate to this question,
however I will reference 'cement' as an example. Basically, cement is a CLI
Application Framework for Python [1]. I am also the upstream maintainer, so I
have the ability to modify upstream or downstream. Currently, cement consists
of three separate sources:
cement
cement.devtools
cement.test
All three pieces follow each release meaning, when 0.8.12 (current stable) was
released... new tarbals were released for all three. The reason for separate
tarbals is primarily for maintaining releases via PyPi [2]. I need all three
pieces to be separate so that users can 'easy_install cement', without pulling
in a dozen dependencies for cement.devtools or cement.test. I don't have the
luxury of creating 'subpackages' in PyPi, so I have to break up the sources.
That said, in the Fedora world... it is a bit excessive to maintain three
separate RPM packages (for all Fedora/EPEL releases)... when all three packages
are related and could easily role up under a single package, with subpackages.
I have the same issue with 'rosendale' [3] which is/will be a set of plugins
for applications built on cement. The same situation exists, in PyPi I need
separate source tarbals because users need to be able to 'easy_install
rosendale.some_plugin'. In Fedora world, maintaining a single package set for
'rosendale' would be ideal and make more sense because I can do sub packages
for each plugin and not have to maintain 20 different package sets.
What I would like to see is if this type of situation would lend itself to
making an exception to the FPG regarding 'one source per package'. I assume
the section 'Bundling of multiple projects' [4] is relevant, though it is
pretty vague. I guess what I'm looking for is for someone with more time in
the community to give some advice on this situation. Ideally, I would like to
be able to maintain a single package set for say 'cement', but with Source0
(cement), Source1 (cement.devtools), Source2 (cement.test).
Or would it be recommended to have a separate tarbal like
'cement-all-0.8.12.tar.gz' which would include all parts of the project, and
use that as Source0?
Thanks for your time.
References:
[1] http://builtoncement.org
[2] http://pypi.python.org
[3]http://builtoncement.org/rosendale/1.0/doc/
[4]
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/PackagingGuidelines#Bundling_of_multiple_projects
---
derks
--
devel mailing list
devel@lists.fedoraproject.org
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/devel
