>-----Oorspronkelijk bericht----- >Van: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >[mailto:owner-developers@;mmbase.org]Namens Michiel Meeuwissen >Verzonden: dinsdag 22 oktober 2002 13:41 >Aan: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Onderwerp: CALL: locations of dtd's Re: [MMBase-1.6.0] Releaseplan >Proposal > > >Gerard van Enk <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >I don't think this is a showstopper. It's a petty but >documentation can be >> >put online easily. There is some documentation and a bunch of examples. >> > >> > >> >+ Excact location of DTD's in jar. >> >> Ok, do we need a seperate discussion about this one? > >Perhaps we can make a vote for this. More or less like the >security. It is already decided that the DTD's will be shipped in the >jar. And I think there are several options: > >1. all dtd's in org.mmbase.resources.dtd (current situation), since > this can be done by build.xml no actual changes are needed. > > [X] +1 (YEA) > > [_] +0 (ABSTAIN ) > > [_] -1 (NAY), because : > > [_] VETO, because: >
> >2. dtd in package next to the class which is using it > (e.g. org.mmbase.util.logging.resources/logging.dtd I already >created - using > only build.xml - as an example). > > [_] +1 (YEA) > > [_] +0 (ABSTAIN ) > > [X] -1 (NAY), because : Because more than one package might be using it (say builder.xml) > > [_] VETO, because: > > >3. dtd next to the class which is using it. (e.g. >org.mmbase.util.logging/logging.dtd). > > [_] +1 (YEA) > > [_] +0 (ABSTAIN ) > > [X] -1 (NAY), because : Because more than one package might me using it > > [_] VETO, because: > > >4. None of the above > > [_] +1 (YEA), because: > > >2 & 3 need actual movement of the dtd's to the src tree, because >otherwise it would become unmaintainable. > > >Since this is not a yes/no vote I dare to express my own preference too: > >1: [X] +0 (ABSTAIN) >2: [X] +1 (YES) >3: [X] +0 (ABSTAIN) > >I prefer 2 above 3 because we have decided to supply several versions >of the same dtd (builder.dtd, builder_1_0.dtd, builder_1_1.dtd), so >putting them in a directory keeps things cleaner. > > Michiel > >-- >mihxil' Michiel Meeuwissen >Mediapark C101 Hilversum >+31 (0)35 6772979 >[]() > >
