16.10.2017, 05:43, "Kevin Kofler" <[email protected]>: > Christian Gagneraud wrote: >> I would resume this post as "I love CMake, CMake is the only way. >> You're all wrong." >> This post doesn't explain anything, doesn't gives any analysis, no >> comparison, no argument whatsoever, nothing. > > It makes one important point (and elaborates it to great lengths): developer > familiarity. Even if QBS were actually a lot better than CMake (something I > am also very sceptical about), it would still be universally hated simply > because it is not what developers (and distribution packagers!) know. > > As a distribution packager, I am really fed up of some upstream projects > reinventing their own custom build systems (qmake, gyp, gn, qbs, etc.) that > don't work with our existing packaging boilerplate.
FWIW, some major open project have migrated to Meson recently [1], so that build system is becoming something that packagers *have to* know how to deal with. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meson_%28software%29#Adopters > >> How many people had the same reaction when clang started? >> Nowadays, clang is actually far superior to gcc, it brought tooling >> like we would never have dared to dream of . > > Yet, Fedora packages are still built using GCC and there are no plans to > change that any time soon. The generated code is simply more efficient. > >> Same goes with SVN vs git, now (almost) everyone have given up with SVN. >> SVN was "CVS in better", git is a completely different approach to >> SCM, SVN is now a zombie. > > Yet, the git way to do things is not necessarily better. Revision IDs are > not comparable without having the absolute history. Developers can commit > their work locally without pushing it, encouraging intransparent > development. And the learning curve is a lot steeper if you are not used to > it yet. > > That said, git nowadays has the exact same argument going for it as CMake: > it is what everyone is now used to. > > Kevin Kofler > > _______________________________________________ > Development mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development -- Regards, Konstantin _______________________________________________ Development mailing list [email protected] http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development
