15.10.2017, 12:20, "Christian Gagneraud" <[email protected]>: > On 14 October 2017 at 04:22, Jean-Michaël Celerier > <[email protected]> wrote: >>> nobody is going to port Qt to CMake (if you disagree start a new thread) >> >> https://plus.google.com/+AaronSeigo/posts/fWAM9cJggc8 > > I would resume this post as "I love CMake, CMake is the only way. > You're all wrong." > This post doesn't explain anything, doesn't gives any analysis, no > comparison, no argument whatsoever, nothing. > > How many people had the same reaction when clang started? > Nowadays, clang is actually far superior to gcc, it brought tooling > like we would never have dared to dream of . > > Same goes with SVN vs git, now (almost) everyone have given up with SVN. > SVN was "CVS in better", git is a completely different approach to > SCM, SVN is now a zombie. > > "Not reinventing the wheel" has to be balanced with "innovation". > > IMHO, Qbs' great potential is the "completely new approach".
It isn't new actually, there were many build systems with similar concepts before Qbs existed, e.g. Tundra [1]. Problem is that such projects tend to be one-man shows and don't get wide adoption. [1] https://github.com/deplinenoise/tundra/blob/master/doc/manual.asciidoc > Qbs would be a failed attempt if it was "CMake&autohell in better". > > I think it's worth thinking about that, and be critical instead of > being blind nay-sayer. > >>> a complete CMake build for Qt was already contributed upstream (quite some >>> time ago) .. and rejected .. > > It would be interesting to know why. Oswald said "we (...) are > strongly biased against a > cmake-based solution", but didn't give any reason/justification (Or I > missed it). > > Did this CMake port cover all the features provided by qmake? > Did this CMake port provide all the configuration needed by Qt, on all > the supported platform? > Could the Qt CI switch to CMake then? > > And what about this "Nominating Kevin Funk for Maintainer qtbase/Build > Systems/CMake" thread? > Will Kevin Funk (aka. "The CMake guy" according to Sergio) be fair > when it comes to evaluating new build systems for Qt? or is it an > hijack attempt, an insider infiltration? > Or is it pure timing coincidence, and Kevin Funk is actually a "build > system*s* guy"? > > I have no power of decision, so i will accept any. > > Nonetheless, I think it would be a mistake to choose a build system > over the other because "I love Xyz, Xyz is the only way. You're all > wrong." > > Who knows, maybe the answer to "Which new build system for Qt" could > be neither CMake, neither Qbs. > > My 2 cents, > Chris > _______________________________________________ > Development mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development -- Regards, Konstantin _______________________________________________ Development mailing list [email protected] http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development
