On Sunday, November 22, 2015 03:19:54 Jon D via Digitalmars-d-learn wrote: > On Sunday, 22 November 2015 at 00:31:53 UTC, Jonathan M Davis > wrote: > > > > Honestly, arrays suck as output ranges. They don't get appended > > to; they get filled, and for better or worse, the documentation > > for copy is probably assuming that you know that. If you want > > your array to be appended to when using it as an output range, > > then you need to use std.array.Appender. > > > Hi Jonathan, thanks for the reply and the info about > std.array.Appender. I was actually using copy to fill an array, > not append. However, I also wanted to preallocate the space. And, > since I'm mainly trying to understand the language, I was also > trying to figure out the difference between these two forms of > creating a dynamic array with an initial size: > > auto x = new int[](n); > int[] y; y.reserve(n); > > The obvious difference is that first initializes n values, the > second form does not. I'm still unclear if there are other > material differences, or when one might be preferred over the > other :) It's was in this context the behavior of copy surprised > me, that it wouldn't operate on the second form without first > filling in the elements. If this seems unclear, I can provide a > slightly longer sample showing what I was doing.
If you haven't read this article yet, then you should read it: http://dlang.org/d-array-article.html It doesn't use the official terminology (in particular, it talks about T[] as being a slice and the underlying GC buffer as being the dynamic array, whereas per the language spec T[] is the dynamic array (which is alsa a slice of some sort of memory), and the underlying GC buffer that typically backs a dynamic array is just a GC buffer and is essentially an implementation detail), but it should give you good insight into how arrays work in D. - Jonathan M Davis
