On Wed, 10 Dec 2008 01:37:00 +0300, Brad Roberts <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

For me, it's not about speed, it's about push vs pull.  A forum that I
have to actively go to to find out if there's new material is wasteful. I
already go to my mail client to find pushed material.. and it's
incrementally much easier for me to subscribe to a mailing list than
anything else.  That's exactly why the first thing I did when joining the
D community was to setup the nntp <--> mail bridges. Any use of forums by
me would require an automatic email gateway.

Just my 2 cents,
Brad


For those of us who read all the messages that enter this newsgroup NNTP is 
more useful, no one argues this.

But those users who visit digitalmars.D just to know if there are any 
interesting topics discussed or to ask a question once in a while prefer 
traditional web-based interface. In fact, these newsgroup have great amount of 
useful information, but you have to fetch all the messages for doing a search 
over them by a keyword (my messages cache is about 800Mb!). This is hardly 
possible for a newcomer. OTOH, any decent forum has a search functionality 
built-in.

I believe that both should coexist, but a better integration between them is 
needed for sure.

Reply via email to