grauzone wrote:
Walter Bright wrote:
Burton Radons wrote:
That's what we said about strings in 1.0. You modify it, you copy it,
or you tell the user. The gentleman's agreement worked perfectly and
that came without a mess of keywords, without implicit or explicit
restrictions on behaviour, without having to condition templates.
The one flaw in it was the behavior I consistently saw of "I'm copying
the string just to be sure I own it and nobody else changes it." D was
meant for copy-on-write, which means copy the string *only* if you
change it. No defensive copying. No "just in case" copying. The
gentleman's agreement failed as far as I could tell.
With immutable strings, the gentleman's agreement is enforced.
What about automatic, built-in copy on write?
No go with threads. COW sounded like a great idea for std::string in
ancient times when threads were a rarity. Today, virtually all C++
implementations actively dropped COW and replaced it with eager copy +
small string optimization for short strings. D really has the best of
all worlds solution.
Andrei