On Thu, 02 Apr 2009 14:32:20 -0700, Andrei Alexandrescu <[email protected]> wrote:
>Georg Wrede wrote: >> dsimcha wrote: >>> == Quote from Walter Bright ([email protected])'s article >>>> Nick Sabalausky wrote: >>>>> If there's one thing my >>>>> school experience taught me, it's that teachers are only interested in >>>>> focusing on the low-to-mid-range students. >>>> That wasn't my college experience at all (Caltech). I was a >>>> low-to-mid-range student there >>> >>> ...Which kind of proves the point that the way knowledge/learning in >>> college is >>> measured is pretty flawed in that it doesn't predict who will be >>> successful >>> afterword. I just finished undergrad a couple years ago and I feel >>> that the kinds >>> of multiple choice exams you get in huge lecture-based classes are >>> good at testing >>> rote memorization and superficial understanding and the ability to get >>> inside the >>> professor's head, where as what's important is the ability to take >>> your knowledge >>> and apply it to something useful or use it to create more knowledge. >> >> Yes, one gets the impression that those who do well in exams simply >> store the stuff in another way in their head. Feels like they've >> developed methods to store it for easy retrieval and rote memorization, >> instead of ever trying to internalize the essence of it. (Sure, some >> kids can manage both, but I wasn't one of them.) >> >> But then, 20 years afterward, ask the three starry eyed ones, what the >> price will be if there is first a 10% price hike and then you get a 10% >> rebate. Since they can't remember the formula by heart anymore, they're >> at a loss with this one. But what does it matter, they've got good >> secure jobs, a nice family and a car as good as their neighbor. >> >> OTOH, to make things really happen, we need the other kind of guys. >> Those of us who want to understand. They're the ones who advance the >> state of the art, and without that, we'd still be traveling on steam >> trains. I just wish there were more schools and pedagogic knowledge (and >> good teachers, of course) to make things interesting and fun for us >> others. But without that, many students get by with so-so grades, having >> invested only 10% of their effort into it. I know I did. What a waste. > >I don't buy 10% of this, after another 10% rebate. I'm not sure you >meant it that way, but it looks quite narcissistic. Not only the kind of >people who operate like you push humankind towards progress. > >We all know stories of lousy-student rise to genius. John Backus, Thomas >Alva Edison, Einstein... You know why? Because they're spectacular >stories. There have been plenty of geniuses who also happened to be good >students, but nobody cares for that detail because it's expected and >therefore uninformative. > >And if anyone is pissed about the quality of higher education in the US, >they'll have to move to Mars. US has the best in the world. > > >Andrei My cat said that might be true.
