2009/6/2 "Jérôme M. Berger" <[email protected]>: > Leandro Lucarella wrote: > I've started. I'll give you a full report tomorrow when I have tested > it more completely, but I have to tell you that it doesn't look good for > Git. Now, I have to ask: have *you* tried Mercurial or Bazaar? And what, in > your opinion, is the main advantage of Git over the other two?
My faves: * Ability to do commits on particular source line diffs so you don't have to do gymnastics to prevent that unrelated one-line fix you made from going into your commit that fixes bug 1234. * Staging area (I think that's what the Git boys call it). Again makes it easier to get just the things you want into a commit, and nothing you don't. I've used Mercurial and Bazaar a fair amount. For personal projects I might still choose Mercurial, just because it's got a simpler model than the other two. Bazaar tries to offer you all these ways to configure a project (from more svn-like central repo to fully distributed) but to me that ended up just making it seem more complicated than hg. But on the other hand if you want flexibility, Bazaar is still not anywhere as flexible as git. This is a fantastic Git tutorial: http://excess.org/article/2008/07/ogre-git-tutorial/ That's the thing that really convinced me that the Linux folks aren't smoking crack and that git really is the way to go, ultimately, even on Windows. --bb
