On Wed, 02 Dec 2009 01:36:54 -0500, retard <[email protected]> wrote:

If it leaks 200 MB per day, people can already run it for a month on a
typical home PC before the machine runs out of physical memory (assuming
8GB physical RAM like most of my friends have these days on their
$500-600 systems).

Notice I said XP. this system had 500MB of RAM, it's not a new system. AFAIK, XP doesn't even *support* more than 4GB of RAM (and I don't think my chipset would support more than 1G). 200MB is probably the most the OS would give it, because I think my typical idle memory usage was 400MB.

Let's just say instead of 200MB, it uses whatever memory was left to consume, ok?

But the memory leak isn't the biggest issue, that is clearly a bug and not a feature. The problem I have is the 10MB of memory it uses to put an icon on the task tray. I see loads of these icons all the time on other people's computers, all using up huge chunks of memory so they can instantaneously check for the latest logitech driver for their keyboard (oooh! what new awesome amazing things will my keyboard be able to do with this upgrade!). It's the computer equivalent to hiring a team of people around you 24/7, and some of those team member's *ONLY* job is to give you a q-tip in case you want it.

And moores law seems to apply to moronic icon developers as well -- the more memory available, the bloatier they make their nifty task tray icons "hey, Windows 7 supports an alpha channel! let's make the icon [that nobody ever uses] fade in and out!"

A typical user reboots every day so a program can freely leak at least 7
gigs per day, (during a 8h work day) that's 15 MB per minute or 250 kB
per second. According to Moore's law the leak rate can grow
exponentially. So in 2013 your typical taskbar apps leak at least one
megabyte per second and most of users are still happy. With a RAM upgrade
they can use apps that leak 4+ MB per second. As users tend to restart
programs when the system starts running slowly, the shorter uptime of
apps means that they can leak a lot more.

I don't know what typical users you know, but the typical users I know do not reboot their computer unless it requires it. Most of the people I know have installed so much bloatware on their system that it takes 20 minutes to boot their system, so they only reboot when necessary.

Your idea of "x amount of leakage is OK" where x > 0 is exactly the developer mindset I was talking about.

-Steve

Reply via email to