On 2/14/10 19:17, Andrei Alexandrescu wrote:
Currently new is baroque to the extreme. Should we eliminate the class-specific allocators in favor of a simple scheme for placement new? All that's really needed is to construct an object of a given type at a given address. All of the syntactic mess around it is unnecessary.
Didn't dsimcha or someone work on an implementation of a precise GC that needed changes to this sort of things. If so, make sure you take those changes into account.
I think class-specific new and delete are not a useful feature. Second, the whole new anonymous class thing is for Java's sake. Do you think we need to keep all that?
Yes I think so. Removing that will break the whole DWT library.
I suggest the following syntaxes for a type T, an integral length, an initializerlist a la "e1, e2, e3, ..." that could be empty, and an addr convertible to void*: new T[length] new T(initializerlist) new(addr) T[length] new(addr) T(initializerlist) and call it a day. What do you think? Andrei
