"so" <[email protected]> wrote in message news:op.vidmzstl7dt...@so-pc... > On Thu, 02 Sep 2010 02:05:53 +0300, Walter Bright > <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Russel Winder wrote: >>> Extremely serious low budget though -- everyone needs to remember that >>> when watching (1974, so pre Star Wars, and a very, very low budget). >> >> Dark Star and the Star Wars prequels prove that big budgets aren't what >> make a movie, a plot and good writing is. > > If you ignore the Harrison Ford factor, SW is nothing but a soap opera to > me...
I don't really see that. To me, the original trilogy at least, seemed like action flicks in sci-fi clothing (Nothing wrong with that!) Now the Battlestar Galactica remake, the V remake, and Stargate Universe, *those* are soap operas pretending to be sci-fi. And that goes triple for Craprica. I really miss the sci-fi from around 1990-2005 (approx). I know a lot of people would probably consider this heresy, but to me, that's the golden age of science fiction. All of the Berman-era Star Treks (none of this JJ Abrams nonsense), the Stargate movie, Stargate SG-1 (even Atlantis was at least ok), Babylon 5 (no spoilers! I still haven't gotten around to the last season and a half), The Fifth Element, Farscape, Firefly (although that was really more space western than sci-fi). Lots of great stuff. But now sci-fi is mostly just soap operas with shitty camera work, and a few well-intended-but-ultimately-mediocre attempts like Warehouse 13, the revived Doctor Who, and Sanctuary (really more of an off-brand X-Men than sci-fi though - and I'm not much one for western comics). Eureka's about the only really good one on (although it still has just a touch more soap-drama than I would like, and sometimes it feels like Carter is the only one really carrying the show). So aside from that one, I usually just watch anime instead. > Then you watch Bladerunner, Alien... now they are truly awesome! Still haven't gotten around to seeing Alien (yea, I know - unthinkable ;) ), but I tried watching Bladerunner once and got bored quick and turned it off. I've been meaning to give it another try though, it certainly has a lot of recommendations behind it. Maybe it was just because I was watching the "director's edition"? Bladerunner fans: Which edition would be best to go with: original, "director's", or "final"?
