Nick Sabalausky wrote:
I don't really see that. To me, the original trilogy at least, seemed like action flicks in sci-fi clothing (Nothing wrong with that!) Now the Battlestar Galactica remake, the V remake, and Stargate Universe, *those* are soap operas pretending to be sci-fi. And that goes triple for Craprica.

So many people like BG that I keep giving it a try, and keep turning it off.

I really miss the sci-fi from around 1990-2005 (approx). I know a lot of people would probably consider this heresy, but to me, that's the golden age of science fiction. All of the Berman-era Star Treks (none of this JJ Abrams nonsense), the Stargate movie, Stargate SG-1 (even Atlantis was at least ok), Babylon 5 (no spoilers! I still haven't gotten around to the last season and a half), The Fifth Element, Farscape, Firefly (although that was really more space western than sci-fi). Lots of great stuff.

Please don't overlook 2001 or Colossus.


But now sci-fi is mostly just soap operas with shitty camera work, and a few well-intended-but-ultimately-mediocre attempts like Warehouse 13, the revived Doctor Who, and Sanctuary (really more of an off-brand X-Men than sci-fi though - and I'm not much one for western comics). Eureka's about the only really good one on (although it still has just a touch more soap-drama than I would like, and sometimes it feels like Carter is the only one really carrying the show). So aside from that one, I usually just watch anime instead.

Real sci-fi is based on a "what if X" and then a story is built around it. 2001 is what if we find an artifact on the moon? Colossus is what if a defense computer becomes sentient? Soap operas, horse operas, etc., aren't really sci-fi even if they are in spaceships. Monster movies are sci-fi, but the genre is so tired (something is killing the crew one by one!) that I really don't want to see another one.

Is Star Wars sci-fi? I'd say not, because spaceships are the setting, but have nothing to do with the plot which you could transfer wholesale to a western or an eastern. The fact that entire sequences seem to be lifted directly from "633 Squadron" also argues that it is not sci-fi.

BTW, watch "Primer". That's some really good sci-fi. No special effects, no budget, just exploring the amazing consequences of a simple idea.

Reply via email to