On Friday, February 18, 2011 17:39:34 Walter Bright wrote: > Jonathan M Davis wrote: > > The prequel movies definitely have some inconsistencies with the > > originals, but for the most part, they weren't huge. I suspect that the > > real trouble comes in when you read the books (which I haven't). > > Huge? How about it never occurs to Vader to search for Luke at the most > obvious location in the universe - his nearest living relatives (Uncle > Owen)? That's just the start of the ludicrousness. > > Ok, I have no right to be annoyed, but what an opportunity (to make a truly > great movie) squandered.
Well, that's not really an inconsistency so much as not properly taking everything into account in the plot (though to be fair, IIRC, Vader had no clue that he even _had_ kids, so it's not like he would have gone looking in the first place). Regardless, I don't think that there's much question that those films could have been much better. - Jonathan M Davis
