Hi Lars,
I agree on your order....but would like to see Matrix ops in Phobos over
time (my understanding was that it can work without BLAS (just slower),
people can always in BLAS when they need to extra performance, no?).
David, thanks a lot for your hard work...
On 18/03/2011 09:26, Lars T. Kyllingstad wrote:
On Thu, 17 Mar 2011 15:33:10 +0000, dsimcha wrote:
I've accumulated a bunch of little libraries via various evening and
weekend hacking projects over the past year or so, in various states of
completion. Most are things I'm at least half-considering for Phobos,
though some belong as third-party libs. I definitely don't have time to
finish/flesh out all of them anytime soon, so I've decided to ask the
community what to prioritize. Below is a summary of everything I've been
working on, with its current level of completion. Please let me know
the following:
1. A relative ordering of how useful you think these libraries would be
to the community.
In order:
1. TempAlloc
2. Matrix ops (I'm biased here, of course...)
3. RandAA
4. CSV parser
5. Rational
That said, it does make sense to start with the things which require the
least amount of work. If it would take you half an hour to complete the
rationals lib, for instance, that may be a good starting point.
Regarding std.mixins, I have to agree with Andrei and the others that
code should be organised by functionality and not implementation method.
Having thought some more about it, I also think std.file is not the right
place for GZip support. Phobos needs an std.compression package/module,
and a method for bulk reading/writing of gzip files may well be a good
start.
Finally, I know next to nothing about machine learning, so I won't
express any opinion about it.
2. In absolute terms, would you find this useful?
Absolutely!
3. For the Phobos candidates, whether they're general enough to belong
in the **standard** library.
I agree with Don that TempAlloc is a candidate for druntime. Other than
that, yes.
I note that others have suggested that the matrix stuff go into Phobos.
As long as it depends on BLAS, I would say that's out of the question.
-Lars
