dsimcha:

>Can you please give an example of where <=, >, etc. are useful for 
>representing set operations?  My naive opinion (i.e. without understanding 
>your use case) is that using comparison operators to represent anything 
>besides partial or total ordering is a severe abuse of operator overloading.<

recent Python versions have a built-in set type, I use them very often, so in 
the dlibs1 I have implemented a set struct with the same API, you see it spread 
here:
http://docs.python.org/library/stdtypes.html#set

Most set operations are doable both with an operator and a with method with an 
English name (the main difference is that the methods accept a generic iterable 
too beside a set, while operators require both operators to be set).

If you try to implement the issubset/isSubset, opCmp is not enough, because as 
you say a full opCmp can't be defined on sets, in D we can't overload <= >= 
among sets.

This is not terrible, because for those two operations I define only the method 
with English name, but this is a small limit of opCmp. In expression templates 
you are able to use the same solution.

Is this usage for the set API operator overloading abuse? I am not sure. I 
think it's acceptablre.

Bye,
bearophile

Reply via email to