On 12/10/2011 12:00 PM, David Nadlinger wrote:
I certainly appreciate the general statement, as keeping ones users happy is one
of the most important, if not the single most important thing, to a positive 
image.

However, please don't forget that there has already been put quite a lot of
effort into making the current version ready for release (I don't think there
are any blockers left, are there?). Addressing all the points raised would
require several potentially high impact changes, which could easily set us back
for two or three weeks.

Also, the soon-to-be 2.057 fixes quite a few codegen bugs, which are notoriously
troublesome since tracing them down takes a lot of effort.

And personally, I'd like to see a new version being released soon because I'd
otherwise have to tell Thrift people to use a Git version of DMD when I post my
GSoC project for upstream inclusion, which I can't postpone infinitely. ;)

As 2.057 will contain a few additions which could potentially require some fixes
before they can be considered stable, my proposal would be to release 2.057 now,
and aim for a quick 2.058 to address both the issues you mentioned, and any
problems turned up by FReD/OS X x86_64 being used in the real world.

Andrei makes a compelling case, but I am also concerned about messing things up for you. What is your schedule like?

Reply via email to