Le 19/02/2012 02:23, Jonathan M Davis a écrit :
On Saturday, February 18, 2012 17:20:41 H. S. Teoh wrote:
On Sun, Feb 19, 2012 at 01:10:10AM +0000, Ben Davis wrote:
[...]

I guess this is a bit off topic, but what you probably want is
syntactic sugar that says "declare constructors matching all super
constructors and calling through to them" and can be used in ANY class
hierarchy (not necessarily exceptions). For example:

class Subtype : Supertype {

     super all;

}

If you want to expose just specific constructors, then there could
also be a shorthand for "declare a constructor matching a specific
super constructor and calling through to it" - so you don't have to
repeat all the arguments. For example:

class Subtype : Supertype {

     super();
     super(string,int);

}

That would then make it an entirely separate issue and completely
not Exception-specific.

+1.

This is definitely something not specific to Exception. Quite often, you
want to create a derived class overriding just one or two members of the
base class, but end up having to copy-n-paste most of the many ctors in
the base class along with their elaborate arguments just so you can pass
through the arguments to them.

Having a way of simply saying "the ctors in this class default to the
base class ctors" will solve this problem in a very nice and logical
way. (I.e., you're sortof "inheriting the base class ctors", although
not exactly, of course.)

Feel free to open a pull request. It would certainly be a useful feature for
reducing boilerplate code in some class hierarchies (though in many, the
constructors in the derived class must be different, in which case it wouldn't
work).

One potential issue though is that not all base classes necessarily share the
same constructors. Which ones would be grabbed? The ones from the immediate
base class? All of them? Only the ones common to all?

- Jonathan M Davis

Well that should be achievable with compile time refexion and CTFE/mixin or mixin template. Maybe this should be inserted in phobos.

Reply via email to