On 29-04-2012 23:54, Peter Alexander wrote:
On Sunday, 29 April 2012 at 21:18:40 UTC, deadalnix wrote:
Le 29/04/2012 03:06, bearophile a écrit :
Jonathan M Davis:

* foreach_reverse is essentially redudant at this point (not to mention
confusing if combined with delegates), since we have retro.

retro() can't replace foreach_reverse until the front-end
demonstrability produces asm code equally efficient.
Loops _must_ be fully efficient, they are a basic language construct,
this is very important. Even foreach() is sometimes not equally
efficient as a for() in some cases...


This is an implementation issue and shouldn't be an argument for
language design.

The 'sufficiently smart compiler' argument is old and invalid. Please do
not use it.


Indeed; at some point, you have to admit that implementation will have some impact on design. We don't live an ideal world, unfortunately. ;)

--
- Alex

Reply via email to