On Thu, Nov 25, 2010 at 3:54 PM, Robert Holtzman <[email protected]> wrote: > On Wed, Nov 24, 2010 at 04:44:42PM -0500, Marc Par� wrote: >> Le 2010-11-24 16:20, Robert Holtzman a écrit : >> >> The best and most practical way is to help them out. The bottom line >> is that we would like every type of individuals to use our office >> suite and to be happy with it. I have yet to be on one "help" list >> or help forum where this question has not been asked and the best >> approach has always been to be courteous and help out. It always >> leave the user grateful and satisfied. > > One of the best ways to help them out would be to (gently, if that makes > you feel better) instruct them that it is customary to do a modicum of > research and try what's found before posting a question to a list. Also, > the post should include the standard information, s/w version, OS, etc. > If you have been participating in mail lists for very long, I'm > surprised you don't recommend this yourself. > >> >> Let's not assume that they can't/refuse"won't make an effort to >> learn and just help them out. After all, they are here for help. >> >> If there are too many of these individuals on our help lists, then I >> would say that our help list has internal problems that need to be >> addressed. This would be more of our problem than theirs. > > This might be true if the contributors to the list were paid employees > or if the posters were paying for help. In that case pandering to lazy > users with an infuriating sense of entitlement might be excused because > one does not piss off a paying customer. The truth is, however, that the > contributors are unpaid volunteers who hang here from altruistic > motives and as such are entitled to the respect of not having their time > wasted trying to guess the problem from incomplete questions.
I have no problem guiding someone who needs to learn how to ask questions. Somewhere I've got that page bookmarked (http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html) and refer people to it occasionally. I too am put off by people who feel entitled to immediate help and abuse the knowledgeable mailing list contributors. In a similar way, it is a turn off to hear some arrogant blather from one of the knowledgeable contributors who insists that everyone interact with the list in a particular way. Both are inconsiderate. Following this thread, I recall no one saying that the knowledgeable contributors are not entitled to respect. They also don't need to waste their time guessing problems. It is a simple matter of someone replying to the message, respectfully pointing out the need for complete information. There is no need to belittle people or beat them up because they don't use CLI. > > This may have little to do with installation instructions but it > addresses the flavor I'm getting from some of the messages that *all* > users should be catered to and the clueless ones not be guided into the > right way to ask questions but be tolerated and spoon fed. I have > nothing against clueless users. That's how everyone starts out but, I > remember being guided (sometimes not so gently) in how to ask questions. > I'm not advocating *all* noobs become proficient sysadmins but running a > few simple searches and trying a few things is a far cry from that. > > As far as I'm concerned there is too much of what I call the servant > mentality on this list. I don't find nearly as much on any of the other > lists I'm involved with, including the ubuntu-users and firefox-support > lists which get their share of newly minted users who barely know how to > turn their computer on. > > Feel free to disagree with me but that's my take on these things. > > -- > Bob Holtzman I do not recall any recommendation that noobs shouldn't be guided to be effective in their queries. F/OSS forums and mailing lists function amazingly well, and mailing list/forum etiquette is common across most of the ones I know about. I too started as a dummy (well, more of a dummy). I couldn't figure out why there was no reply to my question about lspci-v (no space). It took me several days to figure out the format of CLI commands. No one beat the crap out of me; there was just no answer. It took me several days to understand why. It was a respectful lesson about Linux. Considering that Ubuntu/Kubuntu users have been singled out in this discussion... The first post in ubuntuforums is: [sticky] Suggestions on how to get your support questions answered as quickly as possible and in kubuntuforums: Please Read Before Posting/Search before posting (also sticky) It might be useful to point those ()ubuntu or other naive users to these posts. I see nothing wrong with guiding a new user with a few direct words about community software and a link to ESR's smart question site (maybe there could be a LibO "Read This First"). That's not disrespectful. If someone is a jerk who thinks that they are entitled to an immediate answer from well-meaning volunteers, it's not the LibO forum or mailing list's issue to get them straightened out on the honey and vinegar equation. Some jerks are committed to being jerks. I personally don't have much use for them, but I still may answer their query if it adds value for the community at large. Carl -- Unsubscribe instructions: E-mail to [email protected] Archive: http://www.documentfoundation.org/lists/discuss/ *** All posts to this list are publicly archived for eternity ***
