Conyers responds:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/john-conyers/a-reply-to-larry-lessig_b_172642.html
Regarding his peer review argument, that's the most common argument I've
heard from people/scientists/professors here at Yale. Anybody know of any
good articles that refute that? with statistics? From what I understand,
journals like PLoS do a good job circumventing that by having the authors
themselves pay, then they use that money to peer review (I think).

"Congress is not perfect, and I respect Professor Larry Lessig's vigorous
effort to change and improve it. Furthermore, as readers of the Huffington
Post well know, I am firmly committed to tough oversight and great
transparency in government, and I don't mind taking it as well as dishing it
out. But Professor Lessig's
recent<http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/is-john-conyers-shilling_b_171189.html>
comments<http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/john-conyers-its-time-to_b_172536.html>on
the the scientific publishing issue and my sponsorship of a bill on
the
subject simply cross the line. I would hope we could debate these matters,
including both the substantive policy issue as well as the process/campaign
donation subject, without tossing around unjustified allegations. Just as
Congress needs some changing, perhaps our discourse does as well.

To hear Professor Lessig tell it, I introduced a bill that is utterly
without merit and entirely the product of shady special interest dealing.
Without any evidence to support his contention (other than my receipt of
what can only be described as modest contributions from publishers), he
labels my motivations for introducing this bill as "corrupt," accuses me of
"shilling" for "Big Paper," and dismisses the whole thing as nothing more
than a "money for influence scheme." This even though one of the very
columns cited by Professor
Lessig<http://michiganmessenger.com/14135/is-conyers-shilling-for-publishers>reviews
the campaign financing at issue and concludes that "the numbers here
are not large" and that "I don't think the numbers in the MAPLight report
support Lessig and Eisen's contention that the bill is a
'money-for-influence scheme.'"

Apparently, on the basis of this one piece of legislation he dislikes,
Professor Lessig is willing to wave away my forty years of fighting against
special interests, including for example my authorship (along with then
Senator Barack Obama) of an anti-lobbying law that established reform groups
labeled a "landmark" law. I have supported public financing legislation
favored by Professor Lessig since it was since it was first proposed.

In fact, I would have responded to Professor Lessig's charge that I am
beholden to corporate interests earlier this week, but I was busy fighting
the mortgage lending industry to get my bill to provide bankruptcy relief to
homeowners<http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aoyMWtlsj27A&refer=home>through
the House of Representatives this week (I was also focused on securing
the testimony of Karl Rove and Harriet
Miers<http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03/04/AR2009030403445.html>
).

Professor Lessig may or may not know that, last year, the publishing
industry supported a version of the "Orphan Works" legislation passed by the
Senate that dealt with the use of copyrighted materials whose authors are
difficult to locate. This may well be the industry's highest legislative
priority within my Committee's jurisdiction. I refused to consent to move
that bill through the House, however, because I did not think there had been
adequate opportunity for all views to be heard. Would a craven shill for
"Big Paper" do such a thing?

I think I have earned a bit more of the benefit of the doubt than Professor
Lessig -- whatever his motives -- is willing to muster. And so it should be
no great surprise that there is far more to the "open access" story than
Professor Lessig's muckracking tale lets on.

First, there is a serious process issue at stake here. My bill would restore
longstanding federal copyright policy in this area. It reverses a provision
slipped into an appropriations bill in the middle of the night, with no
consultation with the Committee which is actually supposed to write the law
in this area, the Judiciary Committee, which I chair. Thus, Professor Lessig
simply ignores that this so-called "open access" policy was not subject to
open hearings, open debate or open amendment in Congress and itself
represents the sort of process-compromised special interest provision that
he generally rails against. Now the special interests here may be highly
worthy, but an openness hawk such as Professor Lessig ought not countenance
procedural gimmicks just because they yielded a favored result.

My bill lays down a marker indicating that issues this complex, with
important values and convincing arguments on both sides, should not be
decided by a few lawmakers without relevant jurisdictional expertise in the
dark of night with no meaningful public scrutiny or input. Unlike the
measure my bill would repeal, my bill is fully available to the public and
has my name attached to it. If it moves through my Committee, which it has
not yet, it will be subject to full public hearings - and open to criticism
and improvement from all sides.

Second, on the narrow merits of the issue, Professor Lessig and proponents
of "open access" make a credible argument that requiring open publishing of
government-funded research information furthers scientific inquiry. They
speak out for important values and I respect their position.

While this approach appears to further and enhance access to scientific
works, opponents argue that, in reality, it reverses a long-standing and
highly successful copyright policy for federally-funded work and sets a
precedent that will have significant negative consequences for scientific
research.

These opponents argue that scientific journals expend their own, non-federal
resources to manage the peer review process, where experts review academic
publications. This process is critical because it provides the quality check
against incorrect, reckless, and fraudulent science and furthers the overall
quality and vigor of modern scientific debate. Journal publishers organize
and pay for peer review with the proceeds they receive from the sale of
subscriptions to their journals, thereby adding considerable value to the
original manuscripts of research scientists.

The policy Professor Lessig supports, they argue, would limit publishers'
ability to charge for subscriptions since the same articles will soon be
publicly available for free. If journals begin closing their doors or
curtailing peer review, or foist peer review costs on academic authors (who
are already pay from their limited budgets printing costs in some cases),
the ultimate harm will be to open inquiry and scientific progress may be
severe. And the journals most likely to be affected may be non-profit,
scientific society based journals. Once again, a policy change slipped
through the appropriations process in the dark of night may enhance open
access to information, but it may have unintended consequences that are
severe. This only emphasizes the need for proper consideration of these
issues in open session.

I acknowledge that these are complex issues and that there are important
values, strong arguments, and passionate supporters on both sides. And I
look forward to the coming debate. But I hope as the discussion moves
forward, we can focus on the merits. No one is well served by ad hominem
attacks, baseless smears, or a distorted presentation of the facts."

-Adi


On Wed, Mar 4, 2009 at 12:27 PM, Adi Kamdar <[email protected]> wrote:

> Just got this from Change Congress:
>
> Dear Aditya,
>
> You may have heard of Big Oil, but have you heard of "Big Paper"? We know,
> sounds crazy, but check this out.
>
> Right now, there's a proposal in Congress to forbid the government from
> requiring scientists who receive taxpayer funds for medical research to
> publish their findings openly on the Internet. This ban on "open access
> publishing" (which is currently required) would result in a lot of
> government-funded research being published exclusively in for-profit
> journals -- inaccessible to the general public.
>
> A study by MAPLight.org shows that sponsors of this bill -- led by Rep.
> John Conyers (D-MI) -- received twice as much money from the publishing
> industry as those on the relevant committee who are not sponsors. This is
> exactly the kind of money-for-influence scheme that constantly happens
> behind our backs.
>
> Can you call your local member of Congress and ask him/her to oppose this
> corrupt bill -- H.R. 801, The Fair Copyright in Research Works Act? Then,
> call Rep. John Conyers and tell him to withdraw it* *
>
> 202-224-3121 - to call your local House member
> 202-225-3951 - to call Rep. Conyers
>
> Let us know what they said by dropping us an email at
> [email protected].
>
> We've included a script you can use when you call below.
>
> Who's against this bill? 33 U.S. Nobel laureates in science, 46 law
> professors, and groups like the American Library Association, the Alliance
> for Taxpayer Access and open access advocates. Now, Congress needs to hear
> from the most important voice of all: you.
>
> Can you take a moment to call your member of Congress and Rep. John Conyers
> today, to let them know H.R. 801 hurts the public?
>
> Thanks for helping to Change Congress.
>
> Lawrence Lessig
> Change Congress
>
> Michael Eisen
> Co-founder of Public Library of Science and Evolutionary Biologist at UC
> Berkeley
>
> P.S. The new MAPLight.org report is located here:
> http://www.maplight.org/HR801_2009_Analysis
>
> <http://salsa.wiredforchange.com/dia/track.jsp?v=2&c=DCMSBp5uhfbU7QaArJf6BNO5ktXvMww5>
>
> =========================================
> Phone script for calling Rep. Conyers and your member of Congress:
>
> "Hello, my name is __________ and I'd like to let Rep. [NAME] know that I,
> along with groups like the American Library Association, the Alliance For
> Taxpayer Access as well as 33 Nobel Laureates in science, oppose bill H.R.
> 801 the "Fair Copyright in Research Act," that will keep valuable tax-payer
> funded research inaccessible to the public online. This sort of life-saving
> research and information should be open for all to read on the Internet and
> not hidden from the public in for-profit journals.
>
> I am deeply concerned about a new report from MAPLight.org showing that
> sponsors of this bill, led by Congressman Conyers, received twice as much
> money in campaign contributions, as those who are non-sponsors. This sort of
> influence-peddling is exactly what needs to be stopped in our government.
>
> I'm calling to ask Rep. [NAME] to publicly put out a statement opposing
> H.R. 801. Can you please deliver that message?
>
> Thank you for your time."
>
> NOTE: For Rep. Conyers, please ask him to drop bill H.R. 801
>
> -Adi
>
>
>
> On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 11:46 AM, Kevin Driscoll 
> <[email protected]>wrote:
>
>> Taxes is such an essential keyword.
>>
>> I also spoke as a member of a research community that supports and
>> prefers open access publishing. For those of you in departments
>> receiving federal dollars, this could be a good connection between
>> your lives as students and FC activists.
>>
>> Kevin
>>
>>
>> On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 11:32 AM, Kevin Donovan <[email protected]>
>> wrote:
>> > Definitely call on this one - make the case about it being _your_ taxes.
>> >
>> > On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 11:22 AM, Kevin Driscoll <
>> [email protected]>
>> > wrote:
>> >>
>> >> I called my rep about this yesterday. I find calls in support of open
>> >> access the easiest to make as the issue cuts so cleanly across
>> >> partisanship.
>> >>
>> >> If you need to get contact information for your rep, check:
>> >> http://watchdog.net/
>> >>
>> >> Kevin
>> >> - Show quoted text -
>> >>
>> >> On Mon, Mar 2, 2009 at 11:22 PM, Jay Sulzberger <[email protected]>
>> wrote:
>> >> > Free Culturists!
>> >> >
>> >> > Go and speak with John Conyers.
>> >> >
>> >> > Speak for freedom.  Argue well.
>> >> >
>> >> > Go with strong allies.
>> >> >
>> >> > Organize and Go!
>> >> >
>> >> > Go!
>> >> >
>> >> > oo--JS.
>> >> >
>> >> >
>> >> > On Mon, 2 Mar 2009, Elizabeth Stark <[email protected]> wrote:
>> >> >
>> >> >> ---------- Forwarded message ----------
>> >> >> From: Adam Green <[email protected]>
>> >> >> Date: Mon, Mar 2, 2009 at 6:04 PM
>> >> >> Subject: Is John Conyers shilling for special interests?
>> >> >>
>> >> >> --------------
>> >> >>
>> >> >> HUFFINGTON POST piece by Lawrence Lessig and Michael Eisen:
>> >> >> Is John Conyers shilling for special
>> >> >>
>> >> >> interests?<
>> http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/is-john-conyers-shilling_b_171189.html
>> >
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/is-john-conyers-shilling_b_171189.html
>> >> >>
>> >> >> You may have heard of Big Oil, but have you heard of "Big Paper"? I
>> >> >> know, it
>> >> >> sounds absurd, but check this out.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Right now, there's a proposal in
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Congress<
>> http://www.earlham.edu/%7Epeters/fos/2009/02/conyers-bill-is-back.html>to
>> >> >> forbid the government from requiring scientists who receive taxpayer
>> >> >> funds for medical research to publish their findings openly on the
>> >> >> Internet.
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >> This ban on "open access publishing" (which is currently required)
>> >> >> would
>> >> >> result in a lot of government-funded research being published
>> >> >> exclusively in
>> >> >> for-profit journals -- inaccessible to the general public.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> *Why on earth would anyone propose this? *A new report by
>> transparency
>> >> >> group
>> >> >> MAPLight.org <http://www.maplight.org/HR801_2009_Analysis> shows
>> that
>> >> >> sponsors of this bill -- led by Rep. John Conyers -- received twice
>> as
>> >> >> much
>> >> >> money from the publishing industry as those on the relevant
>> committee
>> >> >> who
>> >> >> are not sponsors.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> This is exactly the kind of money-for-influence scheme that
>> constantly
>> >> >> happens behind our backs and erodes the public's trust in
>> government.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> *Can you join us in fighting back? The first step is to join Change
>> >> >> Congress's "donor strike" today * -- pledging to fight the
>> underlying
>> >> >> cause
>> >> >> of this corruption by not giving a penny more to politicians who
>> don't
>> >> >> support reforming our campaign finance system. *Click here to take
>> >> >> action
>> >> >> now. <http://change-congress.org/?partner=conyers_huff>*
>> >> >>
>> >> >> When you sign, we'll email a phone number where you can call your
>> >> >> members of
>> >> >> Congress to ask them to oppose H.R. 801 -- the corrupt publishing
>> >> >> industry
>> >> >> bill. We'll also send John Conyers' number.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> (Already, over 7,000 people have joined the donor strike,
>> withholding
>> >> >> over
>> >> >> $880,000 from politicians unless they support the bipartisan plan
>> for
>> >> >> "citizen-funded elections" -- a combination of public financing and
>> >> >> Obama-style small dollar donations.)
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Who's against the corrupt publishing bill? 33 U.S. Nobel laureates
>> in
>> >> >> science, 46 law professors, the American Library Association, the
>> >> >> Alliance
>> >> >> for Taxpayer Access, and open access advocates.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> But just telling Congress to oppose this bill is not enough. We need
>> to
>> >> >> reform the system that allows the special interests to buy results
>> from
>> >> >> our
>> >> >> Congress over and over again.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> *Can you join our donor strike today-and then call Congress?* Just
>> >> >> click
>> >> >> here to take action. <
>> http://change-congress.org/?partner=conyers_huff>
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Thanks for helping to Change
>> >> >> Congress<http://change-congress.org/?partner=conyers_huff>.
>> >> >>
>> >> > _______________________________________________
>> >> > Discuss mailing list
>> >> > [email protected]
>> >> > http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>> >> >
>> >> _______________________________________________
>> >> Discuss mailing list
>> >> [email protected]
>> >> http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> > --
>> > Kevin Donovan
>> > Georgetown '11: SFS
>> > 630.849.8285
>> >
>> > _______________________________________________
>> > Discuss mailing list
>> > [email protected]
>> > http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>> >
>> >
>> _______________________________________________
>> Discuss mailing list
>> [email protected]
>> http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>>
>
>
_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to