Found a couple: Michael Poynder: http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/newsletter/09-02-07.htm#peerreview Peter Suber: http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/newsletter/09-02-07.htm#peerreview
-Adi On Sat, Mar 7, 2009 at 3:59 AM, Adi Kamdar <[email protected]> wrote: > Conyers responds: > > http://www.huffingtonpost.com/john-conyers/a-reply-to-larry-lessig_b_172642.html > Regarding his peer review argument, that's the most common argument I've > heard from people/scientists/professors here at Yale. Anybody know of any > good articles that refute that? with statistics? From what I understand, > journals like PLoS do a good job circumventing that by having the authors > themselves pay, then they use that money to peer review (I think). > > "Congress is not perfect, and I respect Professor Larry Lessig's vigorous > effort to change and improve it. Furthermore, as readers of the Huffington > Post well know, I am firmly committed to tough oversight and great > transparency in government, and I don't mind taking it as well as dishing it > out. But Professor Lessig's > recent<http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/is-john-conyers-shilling_b_171189.html> > comments<http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/john-conyers-its-time-to_b_172536.html>on > the the scientific publishing issue and my sponsorship of a bill on the > subject simply cross the line. I would hope we could debate these matters, > including both the substantive policy issue as well as the process/campaign > donation subject, without tossing around unjustified allegations. Just as > Congress needs some changing, perhaps our discourse does as well. > > To hear Professor Lessig tell it, I introduced a bill that is utterly > without merit and entirely the product of shady special interest dealing. > Without any evidence to support his contention (other than my receipt of > what can only be described as modest contributions from publishers), he > labels my motivations for introducing this bill as "corrupt," accuses me of > "shilling" for "Big Paper," and dismisses the whole thing as nothing more > than a "money for influence scheme." This even though one of the very > columns cited by Professor > Lessig<http://michiganmessenger.com/14135/is-conyers-shilling-for-publishers>reviews > the campaign financing at issue and concludes that "the numbers here > are not large" and that "I don't think the numbers in the MAPLight report > support Lessig and Eisen's contention that the bill is a > 'money-for-influence scheme.'" > > Apparently, on the basis of this one piece of legislation he dislikes, > Professor Lessig is willing to wave away my forty years of fighting against > special interests, including for example my authorship (along with then > Senator Barack Obama) of an anti-lobbying law that established reform groups > labeled a "landmark" law. I have supported public financing legislation > favored by Professor Lessig since it was since it was first proposed. > > In fact, I would have responded to Professor Lessig's charge that I am > beholden to corporate interests earlier this week, but I was busy fighting > the mortgage lending industry to get my bill to provide bankruptcy relief to > homeowners<http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aoyMWtlsj27A&refer=home>through > the House of Representatives this week (I was also focused on securing > the testimony of Karl Rove and Harriet > Miers<http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03/04/AR2009030403445.html> > ). > > Professor Lessig may or may not know that, last year, the publishing > industry supported a version of the "Orphan Works" legislation passed by the > Senate that dealt with the use of copyrighted materials whose authors are > difficult to locate. This may well be the industry's highest legislative > priority within my Committee's jurisdiction. I refused to consent to move > that bill through the House, however, because I did not think there had been > adequate opportunity for all views to be heard. Would a craven shill for > "Big Paper" do such a thing? > > I think I have earned a bit more of the benefit of the doubt than Professor > Lessig -- whatever his motives -- is willing to muster. And so it should be > no great surprise that there is far more to the "open access" story than > Professor Lessig's muckracking tale lets on. > > First, there is a serious process issue at stake here. My bill would > restore longstanding federal copyright policy in this area. It reverses a > provision slipped into an appropriations bill in the middle of the night, > with no consultation with the Committee which is actually supposed to write > the law in this area, the Judiciary Committee, which I chair. Thus, > Professor Lessig simply ignores that this so-called "open access" policy was > not subject to open hearings, open debate or open amendment in Congress and > itself represents the sort of process-compromised special interest provision > that he generally rails against. Now the special interests here may be > highly worthy, but an openness hawk such as Professor Lessig ought not > countenance procedural gimmicks just because they yielded a favored result. > > My bill lays down a marker indicating that issues this complex, with > important values and convincing arguments on both sides, should not be > decided by a few lawmakers without relevant jurisdictional expertise in the > dark of night with no meaningful public scrutiny or input. Unlike the > measure my bill would repeal, my bill is fully available to the public and > has my name attached to it. If it moves through my Committee, which it has > not yet, it will be subject to full public hearings - and open to criticism > and improvement from all sides. > > Second, on the narrow merits of the issue, Professor Lessig and proponents > of "open access" make a credible argument that requiring open publishing of > government-funded research information furthers scientific inquiry. They > speak out for important values and I respect their position. > > While this approach appears to further and enhance access to scientific > works, opponents argue that, in reality, it reverses a long-standing and > highly successful copyright policy for federally-funded work and sets a > precedent that will have significant negative consequences for scientific > research. > > These opponents argue that scientific journals expend their own, > non-federal resources to manage the peer review process, where experts > review academic publications. This process is critical because it provides > the quality check against incorrect, reckless, and fraudulent science and > furthers the overall quality and vigor of modern scientific debate. Journal > publishers organize and pay for peer review with the proceeds they receive > from the sale of subscriptions to their journals, thereby adding > considerable value to the original manuscripts of research scientists. > > The policy Professor Lessig supports, they argue, would limit publishers' > ability to charge for subscriptions since the same articles will soon be > publicly available for free. If journals begin closing their doors or > curtailing peer review, or foist peer review costs on academic authors (who > are already pay from their limited budgets printing costs in some cases), > the ultimate harm will be to open inquiry and scientific progress may be > severe. And the journals most likely to be affected may be non-profit, > scientific society based journals. Once again, a policy change slipped > through the appropriations process in the dark of night may enhance open > access to information, but it may have unintended consequences that are > severe. This only emphasizes the need for proper consideration of these > issues in open session. > > I acknowledge that these are complex issues and that there are important > values, strong arguments, and passionate supporters on both sides. And I > look forward to the coming debate. But I hope as the discussion moves > forward, we can focus on the merits. No one is well served by ad hominem > attacks, baseless smears, or a distorted presentation of the facts." > > -Adi > > > > On Wed, Mar 4, 2009 at 12:27 PM, Adi Kamdar <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Just got this from Change Congress: >> >> Dear Aditya, >> >> You may have heard of Big Oil, but have you heard of "Big Paper"? We know, >> sounds crazy, but check this out. >> >> Right now, there's a proposal in Congress to forbid the government from >> requiring scientists who receive taxpayer funds for medical research to >> publish their findings openly on the Internet. This ban on "open access >> publishing" (which is currently required) would result in a lot of >> government-funded research being published exclusively in for-profit >> journals -- inaccessible to the general public. >> >> A study by MAPLight.org shows that sponsors of this bill -- led by Rep. >> John Conyers (D-MI) -- received twice as much money from the publishing >> industry as those on the relevant committee who are not sponsors. This is >> exactly the kind of money-for-influence scheme that constantly happens >> behind our backs. >> >> Can you call your local member of Congress and ask him/her to oppose this >> corrupt bill -- H.R. 801, The Fair Copyright in Research Works Act? Then, >> call Rep. John Conyers and tell him to withdraw it* * >> >> 202-224-3121 - to call your local House member >> 202-225-3951 - to call Rep. Conyers >> >> Let us know what they said by dropping us an email at >> [email protected]. >> >> We've included a script you can use when you call below. >> >> Who's against this bill? 33 U.S. Nobel laureates in science, 46 law >> professors, and groups like the American Library Association, the Alliance >> for Taxpayer Access and open access advocates. Now, Congress needs to hear >> from the most important voice of all: you. >> >> Can you take a moment to call your member of Congress and Rep. John >> Conyers today, to let them know H.R. 801 hurts the public? >> >> Thanks for helping to Change Congress. >> >> Lawrence Lessig >> Change Congress >> >> Michael Eisen >> Co-founder of Public Library of Science and Evolutionary Biologist at UC >> Berkeley >> >> P.S. The new MAPLight.org report is located here: >> http://www.maplight.org/HR801_2009_Analysis >> >> <http://salsa.wiredforchange.com/dia/track.jsp?v=2&c=DCMSBp5uhfbU7QaArJf6BNO5ktXvMww5> >> >> ========================================= >> Phone script for calling Rep. Conyers and your member of Congress: >> >> "Hello, my name is __________ and I'd like to let Rep. [NAME] know that I, >> along with groups like the American Library Association, the Alliance For >> Taxpayer Access as well as 33 Nobel Laureates in science, oppose bill H.R. >> 801 the "Fair Copyright in Research Act," that will keep valuable tax-payer >> funded research inaccessible to the public online. This sort of life-saving >> research and information should be open for all to read on the Internet and >> not hidden from the public in for-profit journals. >> >> I am deeply concerned about a new report from MAPLight.org showing that >> sponsors of this bill, led by Congressman Conyers, received twice as much >> money in campaign contributions, as those who are non-sponsors. This sort of >> influence-peddling is exactly what needs to be stopped in our government. >> >> I'm calling to ask Rep. [NAME] to publicly put out a statement opposing >> H.R. 801. Can you please deliver that message? >> >> Thank you for your time." >> >> NOTE: For Rep. Conyers, please ask him to drop bill H.R. 801 >> >> -Adi >> >> >> >> On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 11:46 AM, Kevin Driscoll >> <[email protected]>wrote: >> >>> Taxes is such an essential keyword. >>> >>> I also spoke as a member of a research community that supports and >>> prefers open access publishing. For those of you in departments >>> receiving federal dollars, this could be a good connection between >>> your lives as students and FC activists. >>> >>> Kevin >>> >>> >>> On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 11:32 AM, Kevin Donovan <[email protected]> >>> wrote: >>> > Definitely call on this one - make the case about it being _your_ >>> taxes. >>> > >>> > On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 11:22 AM, Kevin Driscoll < >>> [email protected]> >>> > wrote: >>> >> >>> >> I called my rep about this yesterday. I find calls in support of open >>> >> access the easiest to make as the issue cuts so cleanly across >>> >> partisanship. >>> >> >>> >> If you need to get contact information for your rep, check: >>> >> http://watchdog.net/ >>> >> >>> >> Kevin >>> >> - Show quoted text - >>> >> >>> >> On Mon, Mar 2, 2009 at 11:22 PM, Jay Sulzberger <[email protected]> >>> wrote: >>> >> > Free Culturists! >>> >> > >>> >> > Go and speak with John Conyers. >>> >> > >>> >> > Speak for freedom. Argue well. >>> >> > >>> >> > Go with strong allies. >>> >> > >>> >> > Organize and Go! >>> >> > >>> >> > Go! >>> >> > >>> >> > oo--JS. >>> >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > On Mon, 2 Mar 2009, Elizabeth Stark <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >> > >>> >> >> ---------- Forwarded message ---------- >>> >> >> From: Adam Green <[email protected]> >>> >> >> Date: Mon, Mar 2, 2009 at 6:04 PM >>> >> >> Subject: Is John Conyers shilling for special interests? >>> >> >> >>> >> >> -------------- >>> >> >> >>> >> >> HUFFINGTON POST piece by Lawrence Lessig and Michael Eisen: >>> >> >> Is John Conyers shilling for special >>> >> >> >>> >> >> interests?< >>> http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/is-john-conyers-shilling_b_171189.html >>> > >>> >> >> >>> >> >> >>> http://www.huffingtonpost.com/lawrence-lessig-and-michael-eisen/is-john-conyers-shilling_b_171189.html >>> >> >> >>> >> >> You may have heard of Big Oil, but have you heard of "Big Paper"? I >>> >> >> know, it >>> >> >> sounds absurd, but check this out. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> Right now, there's a proposal in >>> >> >> >>> >> >> Congress< >>> http://www.earlham.edu/%7Epeters/fos/2009/02/conyers-bill-is-back.html >>> >to >>> >> >> forbid the government from requiring scientists who receive >>> taxpayer >>> >> >> funds for medical research to publish their findings openly on the >>> >> >> Internet. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> >>> >> >> This ban on "open access publishing" (which is currently required) >>> >> >> would >>> >> >> result in a lot of government-funded research being published >>> >> >> exclusively in >>> >> >> for-profit journals -- inaccessible to the general public. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> *Why on earth would anyone propose this? *A new report by >>> transparency >>> >> >> group >>> >> >> MAPLight.org <http://www.maplight.org/HR801_2009_Analysis> shows >>> that >>> >> >> sponsors of this bill -- led by Rep. John Conyers -- received twice >>> as >>> >> >> much >>> >> >> money from the publishing industry as those on the relevant >>> committee >>> >> >> who >>> >> >> are not sponsors. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> This is exactly the kind of money-for-influence scheme that >>> constantly >>> >> >> happens behind our backs and erodes the public's trust in >>> government. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> *Can you join us in fighting back? The first step is to join Change >>> >> >> Congress's "donor strike" today * -- pledging to fight the >>> underlying >>> >> >> cause >>> >> >> of this corruption by not giving a penny more to politicians who >>> don't >>> >> >> support reforming our campaign finance system. *Click here to take >>> >> >> action >>> >> >> now. <http://change-congress.org/?partner=conyers_huff>* >>> >> >> >>> >> >> When you sign, we'll email a phone number where you can call your >>> >> >> members of >>> >> >> Congress to ask them to oppose H.R. 801 -- the corrupt publishing >>> >> >> industry >>> >> >> bill. We'll also send John Conyers' number. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> (Already, over 7,000 people have joined the donor strike, >>> withholding >>> >> >> over >>> >> >> $880,000 from politicians unless they support the bipartisan plan >>> for >>> >> >> "citizen-funded elections" -- a combination of public financing and >>> >> >> Obama-style small dollar donations.) >>> >> >> >>> >> >> Who's against the corrupt publishing bill? 33 U.S. Nobel laureates >>> in >>> >> >> science, 46 law professors, the American Library Association, the >>> >> >> Alliance >>> >> >> for Taxpayer Access, and open access advocates. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> But just telling Congress to oppose this bill is not enough. We >>> need to >>> >> >> reform the system that allows the special interests to buy results >>> from >>> >> >> our >>> >> >> Congress over and over again. >>> >> >> >>> >> >> *Can you join our donor strike today-and then call Congress?* Just >>> >> >> click >>> >> >> here to take action. < >>> http://change-congress.org/?partner=conyers_huff> >>> >> >> >>> >> >> Thanks for helping to Change >>> >> >> Congress<http://change-congress.org/?partner=conyers_huff>. >>> >> >> >>> >> > _______________________________________________ >>> >> > Discuss mailing list >>> >> > [email protected] >>> >> > http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss >>> >> > >>> >> _______________________________________________ >>> >> Discuss mailing list >>> >> [email protected] >>> >> http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > -- >>> > Kevin Donovan >>> > Georgetown '11: SFS >>> > 630.849.8285 >>> > >>> > _______________________________________________ >>> > Discuss mailing list >>> > [email protected] >>> > http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss >>> > >>> > >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Discuss mailing list >>> [email protected] >>> http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss >>> >> >> >
_______________________________________________ Discuss mailing list [email protected] http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
