The view of IETF has been clear in our discussions: - Email lists existed before email fraud existed and even longer before DMARC existed, so fraud and DMARC are not their problem. The people who created the problem should solve the problem. - DMARC is a transaction between sender and receiver; mailing list operators are not a party to the transaction, Lists have no role in creating a problem, and they need have no role in solving the problem.
This was made most clear when Ale exposed the fact that this list has no protection against impersonation fraud. Even the most detectable fraud associated with DMARC p=reject is ignored. IETF published the ARC specification, but they never implemented ARC because they don't care about protecting subscribers from fraudulent impersonation. It is not their problem. To the extent that ARC forces a mailing list to care about impersonation, IETF never intended ARC to succeed. Outside of ARC, it is likely that lack of uptake includes the above factors and others: - ARC is implemented at the server level, not at the mailing list level. Lack of communication between those roles may have limited ARC participation by mailing list operators. - Lack of sophistication by participants can also be a problem for every email enhancement. Doug On Fri, Jul 3, 2026 at 6:29 AM Alessandro Vesely <[email protected]> wrote: > On Wed 01/Jul/2026 21:33:01 +0200 Murray S. Kucherawy wrote: > > I would argue that a failure criterion, whether express or inferred, is > a lack > > of uptake. > > > Somewhat agreed. > > > > I think the more interesting line of inquiry is why uptake didn't > happen. Maybe > > it was complexity, maybe it was a lack of endorsement by large mailbox > > operators, maybe it made headers too ugly, maybe making the users take > extra > > manual steps is unacceptable, maybe a mix of those, maybe something else. > > > Asking the operators of the various IETF lists would provide some real > answers. > > > > Knowing that might also help improve the chances of something like DKIM2 > > succeeding. > > > Ending mailing list munging of the From: field was not a stated goal of > ARC, > and it won't be of DKIM2. In what sense would DKIM2 succeed, then? That > it > will succeed to DKIM1? > > > Best > Ale > -- > > > > > _______________________________________________ > dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
