Hi there,

On Sat, 18 Jul 2026, Barry Leiba wrote:

The objection collection period is over, and we seem to have clear
consensus on Seth's objection, among those objecting:

I think we should NOT make ARC historic, yet.

1. ARC is actively deployed and utilized
2. No interoperable replacement is yet published
...
...
Point 1 supposes that there's deployment of both applying ARC seals
*and* checking them; it would be good to have some real data on the
latter -- are they being widely checked and do those who are checking
them find the results useful?

Disclaimer: we handle very low volumes of mail here.  Everything is
done with Sendmail and milters.  I write the (primarily Perl) milters.

About eight years ago we deployed ARC and started checking seals.  As
far as I'm concerned we gave it enough time to make an impact but the
exercise was ultimately a waste of time and energy.  About six months
ago I removed the code.  Only a few organizations add ARC seals to
mail that we receive, and a large majority of ARC sealed mail was and
continues to be very little more than spam from e.g. AS8075, which is
generally filtered on IP.  Virtually all the rest could be classified
by checking SPF records etc., without any need to mess about with ARC
and signatures.  I don't think I've ever seen an attempt at forgery.

To me, all this means that the NPV of ARC is substantially negative,
and I see no realistic prospect of that ever changing.

Point 2 simply asks that we defer a decision on setting ARC aside
until after DKIM 2 is ready and we have some validation of it.

"Experimental" wasn't enough to dissuade me (but I learned from that:)
so I feel that leaving the status quo would be unhelpful.  It means
that more people might get suckered into trying it.  I wish that ARC
had been made historic eight years ago; then I might have avoided
wasting resources on a wild goose chase.  If there is no consensus to
mark it historic, is there a way to make it clear that this isn't the
way things are going?

Could it be marked e.g. "NOT RECOMMENDED FOR NEW WORK"?  Between doing
nothing, and marking "HISTORIC", that's the best I could come up with.

--

73,
Ged.

_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to