On Tue, 20 Dec 2016 22:10:20 -0500 Olafur Gudmundsson <o...@ogud.com> wrote: > +1 > I agree this is ugly as ugly can be but that ship has sailed. > For interoperability sake lets just publish this with a note that > says something like this; > > This is documentation of fielded useful protocol. > This is ugly protocol and it copying it is strongly discouraged. > > Olafur
-1 Seemingly, I am still the sole and only -1 although there are serious concerns expressed by many about not only the ethics, but the eventual rise of a non open and non free Internet and many other valid comments speaking out against the direction this is leading and enabling. I once made a very cool tool, it improved the life of many people as it allowed anyone to take over any pc running a certain operating system with the sole and great purpose of helping more users. It too was published, improved, altered and distributed widely RPZ is like that. It solves a serious problem and helps and is in wide use. Quite obviously this draft is going to be published. I hope that by eventually speaking out I have caused some people to think about what they are doing, whom they are enabling and what this will be used for. I also hope that what Olafur Gudmundsson said, may be considered and I am very much +1 for that. Just to explain my strong reactions somewhat better: Look at the email headers of my email, I am an African. My concerns are real, they are valid. I am not just some troll or whatever sitting somewhere in his mothers basement and thinking up new ways of wasting your bits. I am a dev/sys/ops with decades of experience. Consider that the following is very possible: === RPZ will be legitimized by this draft, it will be used and living human beings may actually die because of server software. === And, this is my final word on this, I apologize if anyone feels that I have wasted their time or offended them in any way. This was never my intention. Andre _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
