Hi Guorong Tian
There are some errors in your draft:
On Sat, Oct 24, 2026 at 03:22:00PM +0800, Foundation wrote:
> 2. Why Not TXT?
>
> TXT was evaluated and rejected due to three engineering constraints:
>
> 1. Binary Overhead: TXT enforces text encoding (Base64/Hex). This
> inflates the binary payload by ~33%, increasing the risk of
> reaching the 512-byte UDP limit.
This is incorrect. TXT RDATA is made of <character-string>s which are
binary content with a 1-octet length prefix. TXT's presentation format
may be textual, but its wire format has no encoding and is an array of
octets. TXT has no requirement that its RDATA be encoded in Base64 or
hex.
> 4.1. Apex Prohibition
>
> The UTXO RR MUST NOT be placed at the zone apex. Adding non-standard
> RRTYPEs at the apex can conflict with CNAME processing.
This is also incorrect. CNAME is not allowed at at the apex.
Mukund
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]