On 03. 11. 26 13:21, Jim Reid wrote:


On 31 Oct 2026, at 12:30, Ted Lemon <[email protected]> wrote:

As for the DO bit, it should always be set, because we should always be 
validating.

No. There are plenty of use cases where DNSSEC validation isn't needed or wanted: armies 
of dumb IoT devices that have feeble CPUs and die when their batteries run flat, stub 
resolvers using encrypted transports that are considered "good enough", 
enterprise networks that can't/won't drink the DNSSEC Kool-Aid, etc. Foisting (unwelcome) 
validation that's doomed to fail in these scenarios isn't going to have a happy ending or 
lead to the universal deployment of DNSSEC.

You're also redefining the meaning of the DO bit. It was introduced to signal to a server 
that the (stub) resolver understood DNSSEC related RRtypes => it wouldn't fall over if 
those RRtypes were included in a response. RFC3225 says nothing about validation at all. If 
this matters, I suppose we can always burn another EDNS header bit to say "I [don't] do 
DNSSEC validation".

BTW early versions of BIND9 always set the DO bit. Even when the name server 
wasn't configured with a trust anchor or wasn't linked with a crypto library to 
do validation. This was unwise IMO. Let's not continue setting the DO bit no 
matter what. Just use it for its intended purpose.

Asking people not to set it if they aren't validating is planning for failure.

Maybe, maybe not. If someone isn't validating - for whatever reason - why 
bother setting the DO bit on their outbound queries? What's gained by doing 
that? How would flooding resolvers with unwanted RRSIGs and so on encourage DNS 
admins to turn on DNSSEC?
We can see have about 48.88% users worldwide [1] behind a validating resolver. That's so close to 50 % that I think we are within measurement error and can say it is 'normal' to validate these days.

If size of signature is a problem (and I want data to support that claim and not speculation, please) _then_ we can invent a signal to send large PQ signatures only to clients which understand them. That's certainly better than DO=0.

[1] https://stats.labs.apnic.net/dnssec

--
Petr Špaček
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to