At 04:46 PM 12/2/2001 -0500, CDK wrote:

>Hello,
>
>This message serves to announce the availability of PRIVACY.LI, a service
>site to foster electronic privacy.
>
>We offer anonymous remailers, which can also RECEIVE mail real time! Only
>accepted form of payment is e-gold!.

I would like to know more about the people who are offering these 
anonymizing services, since, ironically enough, their discretion and 
reputation is essential to creating and maintaining confidence among their 
clients that the anonymizing is really provided as promised.

I went and looked to see who holds the PRIVACY.LI domain name - it's 
recorded as

Debax, Inc.
Lee Nguy
Internet Hosting
Casino Str, Bryan Bldg.,309-95 4537
PH-1200 Palanan, Makati, Metro Manila
Philippines

.. the hostname "privacy.li" resolves to the IP address 212.204.235.51 
right now, and a traceroute to that address suggests that the machine is 
located in Amsterdam -

traceroute to privacy.li (212.204.235.51), 64 hops max, 40 byte packets
[...]
  4  sl-gw12-sj-1-1.sprintlink.net (144.232.217.17)  11.506 ms  11.808 
ms  13.102 ms
  5  sl-bb25-sj-6-2.sprintlink.net (144.232.3.141)  12.724 ms  14.209 
ms  12.692 ms
  6  sl-bb22-sj-12-0.sprintlink.net (144.232.3.209)  198.434 ms * *
  7  144.232.9.86 (144.232.9.86)  14.856 ms  14.496 ms  15.197 ms
  8  acr2-loopback.NewYork.cw.net (206.24.194.62)  84.649 ms  85.654 
ms  83.724 ms
  9  bcr2-so-6-0-0.Amsterdam.cw.net (206.24.193.226)  167.786 ms  166.522 
ms  166.543 ms
10  208.173.209.182 (208.173.209.182)  167.234 ms  168.065 ms  166.979 ms
11  212.204.235.51 (212.204.235.51)  169.205 ms  168.083 ms  168.544 ms

The privacy.li website itself says, regarding the principals/operators of 
the service:

"Company Profile
Actually, this is not to be published here:-) A privacy service like ours 
is best if not too many details are known, we hope you fully understand and 
support this.
The makers of this page are veterans at the chosen subject, and will under 
no circumstances jeopardize your privacy."

.. which sounds like BS to me; these guys want to handle payments and 
provide privacy services, which are both very sensitive tasks, but don't 
want others to know who they are, where to find them, or what they've done 
in the past. (Not that there's anything wrong with privacy - it's a basic 
human right, and a very good thing. But if I'm going to trust someone with 
my money, or my identity, I want to know about both their competence and 
their fidelity, and it's pretty hard to reach that level of trust with an 
anonymous entity.)

I also looked for "Debax, Inc." on Google, and found this page 
<http://www.appleby.net/netscam/FPCscam.html> - which is operated by a 
person who claims that the people behind privacy.li are also operators of a 
privacy consultancy which took USD $2000 as a bank wire from a potential 
client for a Panamanian shelf corporation with a Swiss bank account, 
control of which was never delivered as promised.

It would, of course, be very good to learn that a reputable anonymizing or 
payment-processing service is available for projects of a sensitive nature 
- but I can't say that the information easily available to me has yet 
inspired confidence in this venture.

Perhaps the folks at privacy.li would like to provide more details about 
their personnel and operation? Even assuming, arguendo, that they are 
reputable privacy consultants from time immemorial, I'd still like to hear 
about the technical backgrounds of the people who built the system(s) which 
provide the services - the most honest and discreet people in the world 
can't run a useful privacy service on top of a system which is infested 
with hostile intruders.


--
Greg Broiles -- [EMAIL PROTECTED] -- PGP 0x26E4488c or 0x94245961
Eliminate due process, civil rights? It's the Constitution, stupid!


---
You are currently subscribed to e-gold-list as: archive@jab.org
To unsubscribe send a blank email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.e-gold.com/stats.html lets you observe the e-gold system's activity now!

Reply via email to