Paul, KD2MX, asked:
I looking to purchase a decent DMM and would appreciate any 
recommendations of  specific models. I've had two crappy Radio Shack 
DMMs blow up on me.  Each time I bought one, I promised myself it was 
only until I could get something good ordered and then promptly put it 
off.  Well now I'm DMM-less again and I'm in the middle of installing my 
3080 option.

I'm looking through the Mouser catalog and there are so many choices.  I 
guess I can't go wrong with a Fluke.  Would like something for <$100 but 
I don't want to be buying one again in two months.

No HV or special requirements.  Thanks in advance.

-------------------------------------------------------------

About 7 years ago my Fluke died temporarily. The Fluke was ten years old
then and part of the button mechanism died. While waiting for a new part I
swung by Radio Shack and bought a mult-function DMM from them for about $80.


Seven years later I'm still using the RS meter. My Fluke is back in business
but the RS does a few things the Fluke doesn't and I don't worry about
hurting it as much. Indeed, running a temperature cycle test one time I put
the whole meter in the environmental chamber forgot about it! The case
warped on the RS meter, it got so hot (around 100C). I've dropped it, banged
it and done everything but hook it across the mains in Ohms mode, but it's
still tickin' and still matches the Fluke's accuracy within 1% or so. 

I feel a little guilty about how I've abused the RS meter. Been thinking of
ordering a new case to replace the battered, warped one it now has. 

So I'm surprised that you've had RS meters "blow up" on you! What exactly
did they do? 

There is an obvious difference between the Fluke and Radio Shack meter. The
Fluke displays values much faster. The Fluke is virtually instantaneous. The
RS meter takes about two or three seconds although it's "relative level"
bargraph for peaking adjustments is plenty fast. In my experience, that is
one of the big differences in DMM's these days. It all comes down to the
application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) the DMM uses. Fluke, Radio
Shack, etc., all get them from various chip manufacturers, and the faster
chips apparently cost more. At least the meters they go into do! Of course,
the other differences are in the number of digits in the display (and my RS
has one more digit than my Fluke, which I find very handy at times) and in
the number of operations they perform. One thing that keeps my RS meter on
the bench is the ability to put any old junque box transistor in a socket on
the front of it and it reports the Base, Emitter and Collector connections
and the current gain (hFe) in a moment. As a tinkerer with a messy junque
box, that's very handy! 

As much as I paid for the Fluke meter, if I had to let go of one of them
today, I'd keep the RS meter. The specific model I bought has been replaced,
but they always keep a model that has the same features and which sells in
the $80 - $100 range. 

Ron AC7AC


_______________________________________________
Elecraft mailing list
Post to: Elecraft@mailman.qth.net
You must be a subscriber to post to the list.
Subscriber Info (Addr. Change, sub, unsub etc.):
 http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/elecraft    

Help: http://mailman.qth.net/subscribers.htm
Elecraft web page: http://www.elecraft.com

Reply via email to