Hi, Stephane R a écrit : > First I am a man: Stephane is the french equivalent > to Steve. Second, I never meant that "the diagram > on the right is equivalent to the diagram on the left." > > I say that your left diagram is not equivalent > to Jobst's left diagram.
First, I apologize again for my spelling error. Second, I agree that my left diagram is not equivalent to Jobst's left diagram. I did not (and do not) believe Jobst's pair of diagrams is appropriate for comparing undecidedness with indifference, because his right diagram replaces some of his left diagram's undecidedness with strict preferences. (A?D in his left becomes A>D in his right, etc.) So I offered my own pair of diagrams, in which the left diagram has the same strict preferences as the right has. --Steve ---- Election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
