Warren Smith wrote:
I was contacted by a prestigious musical group to help them hold an election.
The election data and results (pending rechecking & comments by you all)
in anonymized form, are here:
http://RangeVoting.org/June2011RealWorldRRVvotes.txt
Feel free to run your favorite alternative multiwinner election
methods on same data
& report the results. I used RRV,
http://rangevoting.org/RRV.html
So I quickly hacked together something to run it through my old
multiwinner code, but I'm getting unusual results. Could someone check
that they get what I'm getting?
{C101 C102 C103 C104 C105 C106 C108 C109 C110} for birational voting
{C101 C102 C103 C104 C105 C106 C108 C109 C110} for Range PAV (integral)
{C101 C102 C103 C105 C106 C108 C109 C110 C116} for STV
{C103 C106 C108 C109 C110 C111 C113 C115 C116} for Meek STV
{C103 C106 C109 C110 C111 C113 C114 C115 C116} for Schulze STV
{C103 C106 C109 C110 C111 C113 C114 C115 C116} for QPQ
where Range PAV (integral) is like PAV, but each rating is counted as a
fraction of an approval. See
http://lists.electorama.com/pipermail/election-methods-electorama.com/2010-May/026425.html
Sainte-Laguë or D'Hondt doesn't matter for this election, it seems.
If it seems to be right, I'll give the results for a bunch of other
methods, too.
According to the program, the reduction of the ratings to ranked ballots is:
1: C113 = C109 = C108 = C102 > C106 > C110 = C101 > C112 = C105 > C114 =
C111 = C104 > C107 > C103 > C116 = C115
1: C116 = C115 = C113 = C104 = C102 > C111 = C110 = C103 = C101 > C106 >
C107 > C109 > C112 > C114 = C108 = C105
1: C113 = C112 = C108 = C106 = C105 = C102 > C110 > C101 > C116 = C104 >
C109 = C107 > C115 = C114 = C111 = C103
1: C106 > C105 = C103 = C101 > C110 = C104 = C102 > C109 = C108 > C116 =
C114 = C113 > C112 = C111 > C107 > C115
1: C116 = C111 = C108 = C107 = C104 = C103 > C109 = C106 = C102 = C101 >
C110 > C114 > C112 > C113 > C105 > C115
1: C113 = C109 = C108 = C107 = C106 = C104 = C101 > C116 = C115 = C114 =
C112 = C111 = C110 = C105 = C103 = C102
1: C106 = C103 = C102 > C110 = C109 = C105 = C101 > C114 = C107 = C104 >
C116 > C115 > C112 > C113
1: C110 = C109 = C106 = C105 = C103 > C115 > C114 = C111 = C102 > C116 =
C107 = C101 > C108 > C112 > C113 = C104
1: C115 = C109 = C106 = C105 = C101 > C110 > C116 = C114 = C107 = C102 >
C111 = C104 > C108 = C103 > C113 > C112
1: C114 = C111 = C110 = C109 = C106 = C103 = C102 = C101 > C107 > C112 >
C108 > C116 = C115 = C113 = C105
1: C110 = C109 = C105 = C104 = C101 > C115 = C114 = C113 = C108 = C107 =
C103 > C112 = C106 > C102
1: C116 = C107 = C106 = C103 = C102 = C101 > C108 > C104 > C115 = C114 =
C110 = C109 > C112 > C113 = C105
1: C115 = C108 = C104 = C101 > C107 = C106 = C103 = C102 > C105 > C114 =
C113 = C111 = C110 = C109 > C116 = C112
1: C110 = C108 = C102 > C115 = C113 = C112 = C109 = C107 = C106 = C105
1: C103 > C106 = C101 > C114 = C111 = C105 = C104 > C110 = C102 > C116 >
C108 > C115 = C113 = C109 = C107 > C112
1: C106 = C101 > C110 = C109 = C103 > C116 > C108 = C102 > C114 = C105 =
C104 > C113 = C112 = C107 > C111 > C115
1: C115 = C105 > C101 > C102 > C106 = C103 > C107 > C109 > C114 = C104 >
C108 > C116 = C113 = C112 = C110
1: C116 = C115 = C114 = C110 = C109 = C108 = C107 > C106 > C111 = C102 =
C101 > C104 > C103 > C113 = C112 > C105
1: C111 = C110 = C109 = C108 = C106 = C105 = C102 = C101 > C116 = C112 =
C104 = C103 > C115 = C113 > C114 = C107
1: C111 = C109 = C106 = C105 = C103 > C102 > C108 > C110 > C101 > C116 =
C115 = C113 = C112 > C107 = C104 > C114
1: C110 = C103 = C101 > C109 = C106 = C105 = C102 > C116 = C111 = C108 =
C107 > C114 = C112 = C104 > C115 > C113
1: C103 > C112 = C102 > C116 = C115 = C111 = C106 > C110 = C109 = C107 >
C105 = C104 > C113 = C108 > C114 = C101
1: C110 = C108 = C106 = C104 = C102 > C101 > C103 > C112 = C111 > C113 >
C116 = C115 = C114 = C109 = C107 = C105
1: C110 = C106 = C102 = C101
1: C109 > C111 = C106 = C105 = C103 > C107 = C102 = C101 > C116 = C112 =
C110 = C108 > C115 > C114 = C113 = C104
1: C116 = C109 = C107 = C106 = C102 = C101 > C108 = C104 > C115 = C114 =
C113 = C112 = C111 = C110 = C105 = C103
1: C110 = C106 = C105 = C102 > C109 = C103 = C101 > C108 = C104 > C113 =
C112 > C116 > C111 > C114 = C107 > C115
1: C111 = C109 = C108 = C107 > C116 = C103 > C102 > C114 = C113 = C110 =
C106 > C104 > C112 > C101 > C115 = C105
1: C110 = C105 = C104 = C102 = C101 > C116 = C113 = C106 = C103 > C114 =
C109 = C108 > C115 = C107 > C112
1: C116 = C109 = C108 = C106 = C103 > C102 = C101 > C107 > C111 = C110 =
C105 > C115 = C114 = C113 = C112 = C104
1: C113 = C111 = C109 = C108 = C107 = C105 = C104 = C102 = C101 > C116 =
C115 = C114 = C112 = C110 = C106 = C103
1: C110 = C109 = C106 = C105 = C103 = C102 = C101 > C108 > C116 = C111 =
C107 = C104 > C114 = C112 > C113 > C115
1: C114 > C108 > C116 = C110 = C109 = C107 = C106 = C102 > C112 > C105
1: C114 = C102 > C101 > C104 > C115 = C112 = C105 > C116 = C103 > C113
1: C115 = C112 = C109 = C106 = C105 = C102 = C101
1: C106 > C103 = C102 > C116 = C109 = C108 > C114 = C111 = C110 = C101 >
C115 > C112 > C113 = C105
1: C115 = C111 = C109 = C106 = C103 > C108 > C112 = C107 > C105 = C102 >
C114 = C113 > C110 = C101 > C104 > C116
1: C116 = C113 = C106 = C102 = C101 > C114 = C105 = C104 > C111 = C107 >
C110 > C115 = C112 = C109 = C108 = C103
1: C109 = C108 = C106 = C102 = C101 > C110 = C103 > C116 = C115 = C107 >
C114 = C113 = C105 > C112 = C111 = C104
----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
