Hi!

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Jim Davis" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Sunday, June 29, 2003 6:34 PM
Subject: Re: Re: Re: EOS Re: B&H and UPS


> I see no protection for me that a photocopy of my CC back and front is
> sitting in a filing drawer in NY, and copied or stolen or who knows
> what could happen to it. Do you?

I really hoped that B&H would have dropped this practice. I did confront
Henry Posner about the security risk of this long a go on this list, but for
some reason he was very silent for long time after that.

As somebody else here pointed out, scan or pohotocopy of the CC does not
give the shop any protection in the eyes of Visa for example. If they think
that it's safe to trust s scan or photocopy and thus think that the person
actually has the card, then the shops are more stupid than I have thought
they are. Most people on this list for example have done some photoediting
with programs like Photoshop. And I bet quite a few could make a very good
"scan" of their own card with somebody elses number in it. It just is so
easy. Just think about how hard it is to make fake money (well US Dollar is
very easy, but just look at the new EURO's for example) - and people are
able to do those very well. And then think about scanning in you card, just
doing some photoshopping, print it out, feed through the fax machine - B&H
will never know the difference. And if this is what they are basing their
security on...

And then if you look at the situation from the customers view. You are
supposed (or where, if B&H dropped the practice) to fax and image of your
credit card - or email a scan of it. Fax has no security. It's an old
technology, and can easily be listened to. But it might actually be more
secure as the guy trying to listen to it must tap onto B&H line. Email, on
the other hand, can be very secure... but does B&H accept PGP encrypted
messages? Do they have PGP public key? At least they did not use to have.
And if you send your scan without PGP, it's even easier to be "listened"
than old FAX. So in practice you will send a scan of your CC to the world
without any security what so ever. The bad guys can get it easily and then
use the same scan directly to buy stuff from B&H. I doubd they can compare
CC scans from different customers. Technically it's hard, and I'm not sure
if is legally possible. (How long can they keep the scan of your CC?) And if
the bad guys take it a few steps more, they just change some numbers from
the card, so that the CC numbers do not match and thus they can not get
alarm from they DB of duplicate CC numbers - in which case they could
compare the scans...

Well you should get the idea... the practice doesn't give any security - it
just puts the customers CC info to very unsecure situation. Making a
complicate system for the customer doesn't give security. It just gives
false sense of security - and thus lessens the real security.

Besides, I really can not believe that Visa would not give billing address!
If that is true, then the companies like B&H should complain to the Visa -
not the customers. (Unless if the companies really do not wish to make sales
at all then they can put that up to the customers.) And if they do give the
billing address, why not just make a restriction that everything will only
be shipped to the billing address? At least that's how it has been on my
cases (well, at least on the first deals, after that I've been allowed to
give different mailing address.)

Still waiting for B&H to check their security practices,
Hugo

*
****
*******
***********************************************************
*  For list instructions, including unsubscribe, see:
*    http://www.a1.nl/phomepag/markerink/eos_list.htm
***********************************************************

Reply via email to