<<God, I remember when  people were up in arms about him being cast as 
Louis and Tom Cruise as Lestat.  Even Ann Rice complained, and later sent Tom a 
heartfelt  apology.>>
<<The only way to look at  it is what Kingsley Amis said after the premier 
of the film based on his first  book, Lucky Jim.  A lady friend said after, 
"Oh, you poor dear.  What  horrible things they did to your book."  His 
reply: "Why, nonsense.   Not one word on the page of my book has changed."  It 
was actually a decent  film; it just wasn't his book.

Best, R E.F.>>
 
Well, I disagree even with Ms. Rice about the actors chosen for Interview  
with a Vampire but the screenplay was so bad I have no idea if the movie  
was horrible because of them or not.
 
That being said...
 
Does it matter how people get to material?  I read this article today  - 
 
_http://io9.com/5902560/10-ways-self+hating-fans-make-genre-entertainment-wo
rse_ 
(http://io9.com/5902560/10-ways-self+hating-fans-make-genre-entertainment-worse)
 
 
In it is a biggie I hear all the time - "9. Complaining that your favorite  
thing is too popular now."
 
Once upon a time in the Highlander Convention circuit I became friends with 
 and still maintain a friendship with a lot of the cast.  Jim Byrnes is a  
great guy.  He played a character that was a blues guitarist (as he is in  
real life) and did some songs on the show.
 
I think he is a journeyman guitarist and writer at best.  He has a  band 
that is popular locally where he lives and among Highlander fandom they  think 
he is a god of the guitar.
 
As a musician myself and music fan I think not so great but good.
 
But every time I see a geek that would have NEVER listened to the blues  
otherwise if not for liking his character I have to go "Well, whatever it took 
 to get them there."
 
So I agree with REF.  Not one word of a book was changed because of a  TV 
show/movie/comic or whatever.  Just be glad that other people like what  you 
do as well now for whatever reason.
 
As a funny side note I cannot stand the Twilight books.  I have tried  over 
and over.  Working for DragonCon I got to know Stephenie rather well  and 
find her a great person but I just cannot get into her books.
 
At work a very undereducated and condescending of things geeky woman loved  
the movies and read all the books because of them.  All I could say was  
"Well, at least she is reading something."
 
Edward deGruy

Reply via email to